Meridian Audio Ultra DAC D/A processor Measurements

Sidebar 3: Measurements

I measured the Meridian Ultra DAC with my Audio Precision SYS2722 system (see the January 2008 As We See It"). As well as the Audio Precision's optical and electrical digital outputs, I used Pure Music 3.0 to play WAV and AIFF test-tone files sourced via USB from my MacBook Pro running on battery power. Apple's USB Prober utility identified the Ultra DAC as "Meridian USB input" from "Meridian" and confirmed that its USB port operated in the optimal isochronous asynchronous mode. Apple's AudioMIDI utility revealed that, via USB, the Meridian accepted 16- and 24-bit integer data sampled at all rates from 44.1 to 384kHz. Its optical and AES/EBU inputs locked to datastreams with sample rates of up to 192kHz.

In Variable mode, the maximum output level at 1kHz with the volume control set to "87" was 6.54V from the balanced outputs, 3.23V from the unbalanced outputs. (Although the volume control goes up to "99," the Meridian clips with full-scale data at settings higher than "87.") With the Ultra DAC set to Fixed output mode, the maximum output level was 4.85V from the balanced outputs; ie, 2.6dB lower than with the volume control set to "87." All subsequent measurements were taken in Variable mode with the volume control set to "87" or "86."

Both the balanced and unbalanced outputs preserved absolute polarity (ie, were non-inverting), the XLR jacks being wired with pin 2 hot. The unbalanced output impedance was a very low 47 ohms from 20Hz to 20kHz; the balanced impedance was twice that, as expected. With the reconstruction filter set to Long, the impulse response with data sampled at 44.1kHz (fig.1) revealed it to be a minimum-phase type, with all the ringing following the single sample at 0dBFS. The Medium filter is also a minimum-phase type, but with less ringing (not shown), while the Short filter, as its name suggests, had even less ringing (fig.2). Tested with 44.1kHz-sampled white noise, the Short filter had a gentle rolloff above the Nyquist frequency (half the sample rate), this shown by the vertical green line in fig.3; but with a full-scale 19.1kHz tone (cyan and blue traces), many aliasing products are visible. Reducing the level of this tone by 3dB gave a much cleaner-looking spectrum (fig.4)—this filter, which resembles that used by other MQA-compatible processors (footnote 1), is "leaky," but relies on the fact that musical signals with full-scale content above 15kHz or so are rare. The Ultra DAC's Long and Medium filters rolled off very sharply above 20kHz (fig.5, magenta and red traces), with maximum attenuation reached at the Nyquist frequency, confirming that these filters are Meridian's "apodizing" types.

517MerUltfig01.jpg

Fig.1 Meridian Ultra DAC, Long filter, impulse response (one sample at 0dBFS, 44.1kHz sampling, 4ms time window).

517MerUltfig02.jpg

Fig.2 Meridian Ultra DAC, Short filter, impulse response (one sample at 0dBFS, 44.1kHz sampling, 4ms time window).

517MerUltfig03.jpg

Fig.3 Meridian Ultra DAC, Short filter, wideband spectrum of white noise at –4dBFS (left channel red, right magenta) and 19.1kHz tone at 0dBFS (left blue, right cyan), with data sampled at 44.1kHz (20dB/vertical div.).

517MerUltfig04.jpg

Fig.4 Meridian Ultra DAC, Short filter, wideband spectrum of white noise at –4dBFS (left channel red, right magenta) and 19.1kHz tone at –3dBFS (left blue, right cyan), with data sampled at 44.1kHz (20dB/vertical div.).

517MerUltfig05.jpg

Fig.5 Meridian Ultra DAC, Medium filter, wideband spectrum of white noise at –4dBFS (left channel red, right magenta) and 19.1kHz tone at 0dBFS (left blue, right cyan), with data sampled at 44.1kHz (20dB/vertical div.).

Fig.6 shows a conventional examination of the Ultra DAC's frequency response with the Long reconstruction filter. The behavior with 44.1- and 96kHz-sampled data is different from that with 192- and 384kHz-sampled data, with a very slight peak evident before the usual steep rolloff. Peculiarly, the 384kHz response (blue and red traces) is not as extended as that with 192kHz data (cyan, magenta). The Short filter (fig.7) behaved similarly at all three of the sample rates shown in this graph, with a gentle rolloff above each Nyquist frequency.

517MerUltfig06.jpg

Fig.6 Meridian Ultra DAC, Long filter, frequency response at –12dBFS into 100k ohms with data sampled at: 44.1kHz (left channel blue, right red), 96kHz (left green, right gray), 192kHz (left cyan, right magenta), 384kHz (left blue, right red) (1dB/vertical div.).

517MerUltfig07.jpg

Fig.7 Meridian Ultra DAC, Short filter, frequency response at –12dBFS into 100k ohms with data sampled at: 44.1kHz (left channel green, right gray), 96kHz (left cyan, right magenta), 192kHz (left blue, right red) (1dB/vertical div.).

Channel separation (not shown) was superb, at >120dB in both directions below 2kHz. Although the Meridian's noise floor was very clean, with no sign of supply-related spuriae (fig.8), a very low-level tone was present at 500Hz, half the frequency of the signal used to generate this graph. Changing the bit depth of the data from 16 to 24 with a dithered tone at –90dBFS dropped the noise floor by 17dB (fig.9), implying resolution of 19 bits or so. With an undithered tone at –90.31dBFS (fig.10), the three DC voltage levels are well defined and the Long filter's asymmetrical ringing can be seen on the leading edges of the waveform. With undithered 24-bit data at –90.31dBFS, the Meridian output a well-formed sinewave (fig.11).

517MerUltfig08.jpg

Fig.8 Meridian Ultra DAC, spectrum with noise and spuriae of dithered 24-bit, 1kHz tone at: 0dBFS (left channel blue, right red), –60dBFS (left green, right gray) (20dB/vertical div.).

517MerUltfig09.jpg

Fig.9 Meridian Ultra DAC, spectrum with noise and spuriae of dithered 1kHz tone at –90dBFS with: 16-bit data (left channel cyan, right magenta), 24-bit data (left blue, right red) (20dB/vertical div.).

517MerUltfig10.jpg

Fig.10 Meridian Ultra DAC, Long filter, waveform of undithered 1kHz sinewave at –90.31dBFS, 16-bit data (left channel blue, right red).

517MerUltfig11.jpg

Fig.11 Meridian Ultra DAC, Long filter, waveform of undithered 1kHz sinewave at –90.31dBFS, 24-bit data (left channel blue, right red).

Harmonic distortion was very low, the second and third harmonics accompanying a full-scale 50Hz tone at or below –110dB (0.0003%, fig.12). When I tested the Ultra DAC with an equal mix of 19 and 20kHz tones, intermodulation distortion was also very low (fig.13). This graph was taken with the Long filter; tested with the same signal, the Short filter produced a picket fence of aliasing tones. As I had for fig.5, I reduced the level of the signal by 3dB to reveal that, while the level of intermodulation distortion was as low as it had been with the Long filter, the Short filter didn't provide much attenuation of the aliased images at 24.1 and 25.1kHz (fig.14).

517MerUltfig12.jpg

Fig.12 Meridian Ultra DAC, volume control set to "86," spectrum of 50Hz sinewave, DC–1kHz, at 0dBFS into 100k ohms (left channel blue, right red; linear frequency scale).

517MerUltfig13.jpg

Fig.13 Meridian Ultra DAC, Long filter, volume control set to "86," HF intermodulation spectrum, DC–30kHz, 19+20kHz at 0dBFS into 100k ohms, 44.1kHz data (left channel blue, right red; linear frequency scale).

517MerUltfig14.jpg

Fig.14 Meridian Ultra DAC, Short filter, volume control set to "86," HF intermodulation spectrum, DC–30kHz, 19+20kHz at –3dBFS into 100k ohms, 44.1kHz data (left channel blue, right red; linear frequency scale).

With 16-bit J-Test data sourced via AES/EBU, the Ultra DAC did well at rejecting word-clock jitter (fig.15), all the odd-order harmonics of the low-frequency LSB-level squarewave lying at the correct level. However, some non–data-related sidebands are visible; repeating this test with 24-bit data indicated that these were spaced at 458Hz intervals (fig.16). However, it is fair to point out that these sidebands all lay at or below –135dB, and are therefore inaudible.—John Atkinson

517MerUltfig15.jpg

Fig.15 Meridian Ultra DAC, high-resolution jitter spectrum of analog output signal, 11.025kHz at –6dBFS, sampled at 44.1kHz with LSB toggled at 229Hz: 16-bit AES/EBU data (left channel blue, right red). Center frequency of trace, 11.025kHz; frequency range, ±3.5kHz.

517MerUltfig16.jpg

Fig.16 Meridian Ultra DAC, high-resolution jitter spectrum of analog output signal, 11.025kHz at –6dBFS, sampled at 44.1kHz with LSB toggled at 229Hz: 24-bit AES/EBU data (left channel blue, right red). Center frequency of trace, 11.025kHz; frequency range, ±3.5kHz.



Footnote 1: See fig.6 in my measurements of the Mytek HiFi Brooklyn.
COMPANY INFO
Meridian Audio Ltd.
US distributor: MAI
351 Thornton Road #108
Lithia Springs, GA 30122
(404) 344-7111
ARTICLE CONTENTS

COMMENTS
tonykaz's picture

Geez, I've loved Meridian since the early 1980's. I've Imported Meridian, Retailed Meridian and Owned Meridian. Unfortunately, I had miserable marketplace success with Meridian, phew, why?, I sort-of blamed the "Audiophile-nervosa" syndrome that permeated the USA ( and still does ).

Now, the early part of the 21st Century, Bob Stuart is becoming the very KING of Digital Audio.

I still have my love for Meridian.

Congratulations Mr.Stuart, it was a looooooong time coming but certainly earned.

I wish this lovely device had a price like the Mytek ( which should've been on the Front Cover instead of that ML "to die for" piece )

Tony in Michigan

keithsonic's picture

The review notes an ethernet port for use with Sooloos. It is not clear in the review if this can be used to connect a NAS. Would appreciate if this could be confirmed.

John Atkinson's picture
keithsonic wrote:
The review notes an ethernet port for use with Sooloos. It is not clear in the review if this can be used to connect a NAS. Would appreciate if this could be confirmed.

Although my network recognizes the Meridian - confirmed by using the Fing app on my iPad - the Ultra DAC's Ethernet interface seems to be dedicated to the proprietary Sooloos system. With Twonky Server running on my MacBook Pro and pointing to my NAS, the UPnP apps on the iPad can't find the Meridian to use as the Renderer. They do work with my PS Audio Directream DAC, which is fitted with the network bridge option.

John Atkinson
Editor, Stereophile

keithsonic's picture

Thanks John for checking this out. Trust Meridian though to go down a non-standard route. I remember upgrading my Meridian 500 transport to a universal player and asking Meridian if they planned to support SACD. The answer was something like 'over our dead bodies, it is vastly inferior to PCM'. I bought Ayre and looks like I wont be buying Meridian this time either.

John Atkinson's picture
keithsonic wrote:
Thanks John for checking this out.

And now I am embarrassed to say that after all this time, I tried the UltraDAC with Roon 1.3 and the Ethernet connection and it worked perfectly.

John Atkinson
Editor, Stereophile

keithsonic's picture

Thanks John for belated confirmation. Other reviewers have also noted bespoke Sooloos input so odd that meridian has not corrected. I have pretty much opted for Chord Dave/dCS network bridge combination but will check with my dealer here in London as they do both options. From memory you were undecided between Dave and Ultra. Would the addition of the dCS cha ge your mind. Best Regards

gevorg's picture

~19 bits of resolution is a pretty bad start for a $23K DAC.

hb72's picture

T+A dac 8 manages to reach 20bit as does dCS Rossini (though only nearly), while AQ's DF does ca 17bit. Mind this is some kind of a digital interpretation of combined digital and analog resolution, measured at v. low volume signal. Not sure how representative this is at all when compared to dynamic limitations of the ear. Not not to mention masking etc.

Whats important to the percieved sound quality of a 23k USD dac?

SNI's picture

I wonder when somebody raises his hand, at states, that digital filters do not have intrinsic ringing.
You can put your digital signal through several filters, and no change will be seen.
The so called ringing is just the shape of a bandwith limited signal.
As long as you do not violate Nyquist, there will not be any ringing at all.
The ringting will only be there, when you try to put through frequencies above Nyquist.
In the passband, where the audio signal is situated, the are absolutely no ringing at all.
I think TI´s PCM1792/1794 chips are the ones with the steepest and deepest filters available (stapband attenuation -130 dB), and they state the passband ripple @ ±0.00001 dB.
Which is practically nothing.
So what you do with theese slow roll off non phase linear filters, is actually hunting down ghoests at the cost of introducing phase problems outside the audio band.

Way too many audio enthusiasts believe, that the "ringing" is a part of the audio signal, as a result of the misunderstandings of this measurement in the HIFI press.
You can only use the impulse measurements to see, if the filter is phase linear or not, and to see the depth of the filter.
Regarding phase linearity, then theese minimum phase filters are the first and only attemps I know, that tries to make you like phase errors.
Regarding the depth of the filter, this points solely to the signal delay through the filter, which is of vast interest for "On Stage" purposes, as it is very hard to sing or play properly, if your monitors are delayed.

X