Spin Doctor #19: An exotic Audio-Technica cartridge and a Vivid flagship speaker Page 2

A Few Thoughts On Stylus Cleaning
All the rules for keeping the ART1000x's stylus clean got me thinking about the methods for cleaning that tiny chip of diamond. Before you even attempt to clean your stylus, you need to be able to see what you're doing. We are fortunate to live in an era when inexpensive digital microscopes are widely available; they are a welcome aid for inspecting a cartridge's tiny parts. For cartridges that are mounted on a removable headshell, I use a small, standmounted scope with a built-in screen, by Annlov. For fixed-shell 'arms, I use a handheld version that plugs into my laptop. Each one cost around $40.

When you use a digital microscope, it's important to remain aware of where the plastic shroud around the lens is as you zoom in and focus; the last thing you want to do is bump into your stylus.

Looking at the stylus from the side under the scope, you will be able to see any fluff, goopy crud, or baked-on deposits and to know when you have removed them thoroughly. This can be a revelation.

The best method for cleaning the stylus remains the subject of much debate and occasional dire warnings from manufacturers. The best generic advice is to follow the manufacturer's instructions. A cartridge-setup customer once received a cartridge back from a factory rebuild in Japan with a hand-written note urging them to "stop painting your stylus." Some manufacturers, like Audio-Technica with the ART1000x, tell you to never use fluids, while others, like Lyra, sometimes include a brush and a bottle of fluid with the cartridge.

I have a few opinions about what's safe to do and what isn't. Plus, I spoke with a few people who handle even more cartridges than I do, including JR Boisclair from Wally Tools, Steven Leung from VAS Audio, and Peter Ledermann from SoundSmith. They mostly agreed with my thoughts. Boisclair says he always wet cleans the stylus before inspecting a cartridge but avoids fluids that contain alcohol. Leung instructs his rebuild customers not to use fluids, though he's mainly concerned about applying the fluid in a sloppy way. Some fluids come with a long, soft application brush, and if you're not careful, you can stick the wet brush up into the cartridge's generator, potentially damaging the fragile coils. My preferred method is to apply one drop of fluid to a small, short-nap pad then get up close with good lighting and some reading glasses.

I then brush the stylus only from back to front using six strokes before inspecting it again with the scope.

I try to steer clear of fluids that contain alcohol. I am currently using an enzymatic fluid that seems to be safe and effective. Sold under different brand names, the fluid from Audio Intelligent Vinyl Solutions (footnote 3) comes in a small plastic bottle with a dropper tip, accompanied by a pad-style brush as described above. Sierra Sound owner Michael Fajen tells me that his fluid, branded Sierra Sound (footnote 4), is identical and from the same supplier, but his version comes in a brown glass bottle with a long, floppy brush built into the cap. The Sierra Sound fluid is less expensive, at $30, but I prefer the dropper-bottle tip and pad brush that comes with the $40 Audio Intelligent Vinyl Solutions fluid. Both bottles are big enough to last a lifetime.


Vivid's Chief Technical Director Laurence “Dic” Dickie with the Moya M1.

A New Jersey Retailer Rolls Out the New Flagship Speaker from Vivid
Over the last 40 years, I've had the good fortune to hear literally thousands of audio setups, but one that is truly dialed in and optimized is elusive. Hi-fi shows may seem like a good bet, but too often they involve listening in a hotel room with lousy, untreated acoustics and a collection of gear assembled and set up over a couple of days at best. Good setup isn't that simple or quick. So when I get an invitation to hear a system that promises to be something special, I'm ready to fire up the old Mercedes diesel and hit the road.

Recently I was invited by Bill Parish, the owner of GTT Audio & Video (footnote 5), to come to his residential retail store and hear an exquisite system built around Vivid Audio's new flagship speaker, the Moya M1. Vivid cofounder and Chief Technical Director Laurence Dickie was going to be there to fine-tune the setup and explain the technology. GTT is located in New Jersey, about 50 miles west of the George Washington Bridge, one of my main escape routes from Manhattan. This part of The Garden State, with green rolling hills, is very different from the gritty industrial image many hold of New Jersey from the opening credits of The Sopranos.

To call GTT a home-based dealer does it a disservice. It feels more like someone built a beautiful high-end audio store with several custom-designed listening rooms then dropped a house on top of it.

The Moya M1s were set up in GTT's 35' × 20' big room, built specifically for demonstrating this type of next-level system. Everything has been carefully optimized over the years he has been in this space: AC power, climate control, furnishings, and room acoustics. I first heard the Moyas in May 2024 at High End Munich, where they were demonstrated in a prefabricated sound cabin on the main show floor, but that environment could only provide a taste of what this speaker can deliver. GTT's much larger, carefully optimized space allowed the big Moyas to show what they were capable of.

In building a system to complement the Moyas, Parish spared no expense. Knowing that the Spin Doctor was coming, he put extra focus on the record-playing system: the latest Kronos Discovery turntable and Discovery RS tonearm partnered with a My Sonic Lab Platinum Signature cartridge. Electronics were by Audionet, including the PAM G2 phono stage, Stern line stage, and two pairs of Heisenberg monoblocks. All cabling was by Kubala-Sosna, and the digital front-end was by Auralic and Master Fidelity.

If you were to pull out your calculator and tot up all of the numbers, you'd find that this system comes to more than $1.2 million including the $465k Moya M1s—so, truly an oligarch-level system, as my friend Herb Reichert would say.

Laurence Dickie, or Dic, as he prefers to be addressed, hatched the Moya M1 project when he was stuck in a hotel room for 10 days during a COVID travel quarantine: Remember those? With no way to get to his design studio in England or to the Vivid factory in South Africa, he started to dream big, sketching out ideas for a truly unrestricted loudspeaker. Dic says bass capability is the output-limiting factor with most speakers, so he gave the Moya no fewer than eight 9" woofers, four on each side of the enclosure, each one physically coupled to its opposing twin to cancel energy that would otherwise couple to the cabinet. The Moya is a five-way design, with 13 drivers per speaker. With that much firepower, I'm impressed it isn't even bigger than it is. Most of the Moya's bulk comes from its extremely deep cabinet, which contains the tapered damping tubes for those eight woofers. Those damping tubes are one of Dic's signature design elements, going all the way back to his work at Bowers & Wilkins, where he developed the distinctive Nautilus loudspeaker with its snail-shaped woofer damper.

Walking into the big room, I was greeted by Bill and Dic, fellow audio writer Greg Weaver, Joe Kubala from Kubala-Sosna cables, Vivid Audio representative Ewald Verkerk, and Dick Diamond from GTT. Everyone else, including Greg, had already spent several days enjoying the system, so I was generously offered the prime listening seat for my whole six-hour stay. After some lovely but not especially challenging music, which I honestly forgot to take note of, Bill asked me what I wanted to hear. Putting on my best Herb Reichert voice, I asked for some rock'n'roll.

Bill must be a good judge of age or something, because he pulled out many of the records that defined my youth, starting with a 12" single of David Bowie's "Cat People."

"Cat People" amply demonstrated what you can do with 16 9" woofers biamped with more than 2kW per speaker. But this was more than just a brutal show of power, bass, and volume. The Moya speakers demonstrated that they were masters of subtlety, transparency, and detail, generating a massive, layered soundstage with pinpoint images.

Sticking with vinyl, Bill played "Bluesville" from Count Basie's 88 Basie Street, specifically the 2003 45rpm reissue from Analogue Productions (AJAZ 2310-901). "Bluesville" showed off the Moya's uncanny scale and volume, replicating Basie's big band with verve and power.

This is not a review; my audition was far too brief for that, but it did show that when no compromises are made, the results can be stunning.


Footnote 3: Sierra Sound, PO Box 510, Wilton, CA 95693. Email: info@sierrasound.net Web: sierrasound.net.

Footnote 4: Audio Intelligent Vinyl Solutions, PO Box 232, Hallsville, MO 65255. Tel: (573) 696-3551. Web: audiointelligent.com.

Footnote 5: GTT Audio & Video, Long Valley, NJ. Tel: (908) 850-3092 Email: av@gttaudio.com Web: Gttaudio.com.

ARTICLE CONTENTS

COMMENTS
supamark's picture

but you didn't include Peter Ledermann's advice for cleaning your cartridge tip - using blue tack. I mean, the guy actually designs and builds carts so he might know a thing or two and it's totally dry. You won't bend or damage the cantilever on accident or leave residue on the stylus.

Also, I think a more whimsical name for the AT cart would be, "The Carbuncle."

Seeing the Moya M1 next to an actual adult human really drives home how freakin' big that speaker is. Also, Mr. Dickie and I have the same taste in footwear!

Andrei's picture

I have not seen the vid of Ledermann recommending blue tack. But this makes a lot of sense.

supamark's picture

https://www.sound-smith.com/how-care-new-or-soundsmith-rebuilt-cartridges

They may only mean it for their carts, but I don't see why it wouldn't be effective for most others.

Glotz's picture

-Mula... Doesn't even fit in the subject line! (lol) I've used their #6 Formula for LP's with a machine and the product is fantastic.

I've been on the fence for a while now with this ESCF (lol) because I use the Lyra SPT and the Last #4 stylus cleaners to great effect (as well as Stylast- it does no harm from 40 years of experience- only reducing friction wear).

I will ponder on that and Sierra Sound product as I like the quantity vs. price ratio here. Perhaps important to mention, one gets exponentially less with the aforementioned products. Spill the tiny finger bottle and you are out 60 bucks real quick (esp. since the Lyra has 2 caps?!). SOMEbody owes me money!

One thing I do with the enormously long Last #4 cap brush is do just the tip of the stylus or brush on to a short stiff bristle brush and then apply. The brush is so long that it will get just enough material onto the bristle face, just fine.

Then I follow with my main every side dry brush- The Art Dudley Master Phono Boner Cartridge Brush - A sable Winsor & Newton flat brush cut to varying lengths of stiffness vs. softness. It's like the cartridge screams out in ecstasy every time I follow up with a swipe! This was a brush from his Listener mag.

And, I don't like the Lyra tiny brushes at all. It's like they were developed by cartridge engineers??

For extended care or infrequent maintenance, like wrapped clothing fibers I use the DS Audio ST-50 (and once a week or two dip as a general cleaning check).

And like any self-loathing vinyl addict, I also use the Flux HiFi - Sonic Electronic Stylus Cleaner. Just another great way to really buff that stylus clean, every week or two.

Another great column dude. I simultaneously lust and loathe after that Audio Technica cart. It would scare me to get near it!

adrianwu's picture

Dirty stylus comes from dirty LPs. When we handle LPs, even if we only touch the edge of the records, the oil on our fingers is transferred to the edge. The stylus then spreads the oil from the lead in groove to the rest of the LP during play. This oil attracts dust and dirt. Static also attracts dust. I always wear cotton gloves when handling LPs, and clean the records with my Degritter ultrasonic machine before play. I also use an anti-static ioniser during play (an industrial one, not those sold to audiophiles at 10x the actual cost). My stylus remains dirt free and I don't remember the last time I needed to clean it.

Glotz's picture

I imagine you would be willing to help over-charged audiophiles find a great ioniser.

My guess is it's sourced in the UK or Europe?

I did find this in the US via Amazon- https://www.amazon.com/Ionizing-Eliminator-Antistatic-Electrostatic-Discharge/dp/B093LBDMN2

adrianwu's picture

The one you show has a fan. I use this one, which is fanless.
https://www.ebay.com/itm/204887167789

Glotz's picture

And it's the lowest price vs Amazon or others. Double thanks!!

Every DS Audio shopper should look at this first. There are no fans in this one, so silent and it's only 5x5 inches roughly.

adrianwu's picture

Also more powerful than the DS unit. It covers a larger area. I have a static meter and within 3 seconds of turning on the ionizer, the static charge on the LP surface drops to undetectable level.

Glotz's picture

I will buy this unit soon. This is an excellent find of the highest caliber in our audio hobby and you need to yell it to everyone you talk about anti-static products and approaches to eliminating it.

Dust is pure evil.

ejlif's picture

always when handling a record. My God that is just way to much

volvic's picture

I think, and I've wondered this myself for quite some time, that there are more than a handful of OCD audiophiles who use cotton gloves when handling their records and priceless hi-fi gear. On more than one occasion, I have seen Audiogon sellers proudly advertise that they use white gloves to maintain their components in pristine condition.

adrianwu's picture

It just takes a second, but saves a lot of time and aggravation when dealing with noisy records. I am surprised most people don't do it. I guess they don't realize how effective this is.

Glotz's picture

for the anti-static device for under $500, I do not find that oils will ever migrate from the edge of an LP to the grooves (unless you are currently eating a greasy pizza). Well-trusted reviewers and technicians do not acknowledge this fear of oil migration.

I also don't believe you need fully wet clean your record each time you play a record. Keep in mind that by the time you move the clean record from the Degritter to the 'table you will have dust accumulate- on the surface of the LP.

A dry brush like MoFi's rubber brush is king for that (with an anti-stat treatment of some type (I use the Furutech but will buy and use your excellent solution). The Smithsonian might recommend wet cleaning before each play, but I feel they are out of touch and their findings antiquated. It's just too much work for dust removal. The grooves are already ultra-clean with the Degritter.

That being said, I really don't want to come off disrespectful simply because of my opinions and experience. Please do you and do it loudly!

You found all of us an AMAZING find that is rarely ever found in this modern world of 'leave no stone unturned'.

adrianwu's picture

My work desk has a glass top and I can see the smudges from my hands at the end of every work day. I don't eat pizza at work, and in fact I wash my hands between every patient I examine.
I built a large part of my system myself, including all the amplifiers, cables and the speakers. Everything is based on experimentation, measuring, listening and endless tweaking. I am the last person to fall for audiophile nonsense such as expensive cables, hundred dollar fuses and boutique capacitors (and I have stories to tell about those). Wearing gloves is what I found the most helpful when trying to eliminate noise from playing LPs. Your mileage may vary.

Glotz's picture

Your experiences are valid and no denigration intended. I wasn't suggesting you eat pizza around your LP's.

Your experiences may show you expensive cables and fuses do work. Your style works for you now. Tell any stories you feel...

X