Columns Retired Columns & Blogs |
"This, of course, illustrates the danger of making absolute pronouncements on sound quality based on unknown recordings." --JA
You betcha. That's one reason that we stress, over and over, that our show blogs are reports rather than reviews.
John also points to a big problem that both consumers and sometimes consuming/occasionally consumptive press experience when they encounter a server filled with unfamiliar tracks. While my recent Don't Play It Again, Sam! editorial [http://www.stereophile.com/content/dont-play-it-again-sam#3uuHAxoA4SdRqjmt.97] underscores the problem of playing the same relatively few tracks in room after room for year after year - yawn! - it's also true that when only a few rooms allow people to play their favorite well-recorded tracks, we are left without a reference. I've discussed the pros and cons of allowing visitors free reign as well, having previously profiled the sad saga of SF Symphony recording producer/engineer Jack Vad finding his superb recordings rejected by exhibitor after exhibitor. Please see: http://www.stereophile.com/content/play-or-not-play#Fr7VvCIxT1JJHRZ5.97
It's a tough balance to achieve, that's for certain. No easy answers. Ditto for whatever questions are asked in the next Presidential debate.