Analog Corner #275: Bergmann Audio Galder turntable & Odin tonearm Page 2

Later, thanks to Tim Sheridan and Andy Payor, I learned about annular-gap turbulence in captured air bearings: the air under pressure in the zone of operation must quickly return to ambient air pressure at the point where the air exits the bearing, which produces a pretty violent high-frequency oscillation similar to what happens when you inflate a balloon and then let go of it.

Even Rockport's ultra-costly groove compensated air-bearing arm, which eliminated annular-gap turbulence, and effectively dealt with differential horizontal and vertical masses—and, thus, different resonant frequencies—had its own problems, particular one of wimpy bass.

So I approached this review of the Bergmann Odin with some skepticism. I'm skeptical of tangential trackers generally, and consider the amount of distortion created by a pivoted tonearm's linear tracking error (LTE) negligible compared to the cumulative distortions of tangential-tracking arms.

The Odin has a longish armtube of aluminum and carbon fiber, fitted with a decoupled counterweight; the arm's effective mass is 14gm. The wiring is high-quality, super-thin, compliant copper Litz, terminated with gold-plated copper clips at the cartridge end and, at the other, a five-pin DIN jack.

VTA and SRA are adjustable, though not on the fly, which anyway I think is unnecessary as long as you set it, using a digital microscope, to about 92°—"about" because of the measured range of cutting-stylus angles cited in Jon M. Risch and Bruce R. Meier's "More than One Vertical Tracking Angle," the classic article originally published in the March 1981 issue of Audio. In the 1980s, Risch and Meier measured cutting-stylus SRAs at mastering studios all over America. They learned not only that they varied from 91° to 94°, but that the angle had to be greater than 90°, so that the vacuum could suck away the flammable thread of lacquer left behind by the cutting stylus. So, yes, the perfect solution for every record isn't 92° or 93°, as some suggest, to compensate for playback-stylus deflection but for sure, setting the tonearm parallel to the record surface, as is still recommended by too many makers of tonearms, guarantees nothing. Nor is the solution setting it by ear, if your starting point is nowhere near 92°.

Setting overhang—or, better, evenhang, because the stylus's line of travel should bisect the spindle (if it could get that far)—is relatively easy on the Odin. Setting the SRA requires loosening two bolts, so that you can raise or lower the rail along which the arm travels. A level rail is essential; Bergmann supplies a spirit level that's machined to perch on the rail.

While the manual says that the Odin's azimuth is adjustable, it wasn't possible with my review sample. Hopefully, it's coming soon.

The Odin's rail is fixed at both ends. Along its top surface is a row of 18 pinholes, from which low-pressure air constantly flows. The bearing employs a sleeve that slides along the rail on a thin film of air. Only the area of the sleeve directly above the rail is pressurized. Too much pressure would raise the sleeve too high, until its bottom scraped along the bottom of the rail. Too little pressure and sleeve couldn't rise high enough to produce a friction-free ride. At any given point in its travel, the 3"-long sleeve covers only 9 of the rail's 18 holes, to ensure that, between tube and rail, there is always a cushion of air of just the right thickness for virtually frictionless movement.

718acorn.charts

Fig.1 Bergmann Audio Galder, speed stability data (left) and Fig.2 Bergmann Audio Galder, speed stability (right, raw frequency yellow; low-pass filtered frequency green).

Speed and Resonant Frequency
The Galder turntable's speed adjustability meant that it was easy for me to get it to run at the correct speed. More important, its consistency of rotation speed was outstanding, more or less matching the excellent performance of a preproduction unit of Technics' SL-1000R Direct Drive 'table, though the Feickert Analogue Platter Speed graphics (figs.1 & 2) don't look as "pretty."

718acorn.hfn

I used Hi-Fi News & Record Review's Test Record (LP, Hi-Fi News HFN 001). The lateral resonant frequency of the Odin tonearm with a Lyra Atlas SL cartridge was about 10Hz, the vertical resonant frequency about 9Hz. All good, and the numbers speak for themselves: Johnnie Rasmussen has done his tonearm homework.

The Galder is among the best-isolated turntables I've ever banged on. When I tapped or even rapped on the plinth or the base it rests on, nothing made it through the speakers. That's unusual, especially for a suspensionless turntable, and must be at least partly due to the decoupling effects of the air-bearing arm and platter.

Use
The Bergmann Galder is one of the easiest, most convenient air-bearing, vacuum-holddown turntables I've ever used. At the beginning of a listening session, you push the appropriate speed button once to start the flow of air. Press it again to start the platter spinning. It's designed to get up to speed slowly, to lengthen the life of the drive belt. Once it's up to speed, you can leave it spinning the entire time. Don't worry about scratching a record by placing it on the spinning platter—the "lips" of the vacuum holddown cushion the drop. That done, place the puck over the spindle, and the record is sucked down against the mat. Remove the puck, and it's easy to lift the record off of the platter.

The Galder and Odin have been in constant use here since Johnnie Bergmann installed them in mid-January. They performed flawlessly the entire time. Not once did the Odin stick—something that can destroy a cartridge's cantilever—nor did anything require adjusting or tweaking. The air pump was silent. There was no bad news.

Sound
I tried a range of cartridges in the Odin after using them in the Swedish Analog Technologies tonearm with the Continuum Audio Labs Caliburn turntable, and I made a few 24-bit/96kHz recordings that later confirmed my real-time observations.

718acorn.unknow

The Odin-Galder's bass control and extension were both very good, and better than I'd expected, based on my previous experiences with air-bearing arms. I heard nothing wimpy or less than fully extended from a series of LPs, including The Unknowable, by saxophonist Dave Liebman and percussionists Tatsuya Nakatani and Adam Rudolph (2 45rpm LPs, RareNoise RNR 089), a new album with mystical Zen overtones filled with drums, gongs, and a dizzying variety of unusual percussion instruments. "Benediction (Opening)" has some ridiculously deep rumblings—especially if you accidentally play it at 33 1/3rpm, as I did at first—there's no indication of the correct speed!

There's nothing at all polite about this trio's dynamic performance, and macrodynamics and general slam were equally generous. Aural images were stable and well-focused, and the soundstage seemed actually somewhat wider than through my reference SAT-Caliburn record player—especially when I compared files of the last five minutes or so of a reissue of pianist Earl Wild performing Gershwin's Rhapsody in Blue with Arthur Fiedler and the Boston Pops (LP, RCA Living Stereo/Analogue Productions LSC-2367).

However, the picture's bigger size was partly due to somewhat more diffuse and larger images. The far more expensive SAT-Caliburn combo produced greater precision and focus of images, as well as more sharply drawn transients, but I'm sure that when I play these files at audio shows, more listeners will prefer the Bergmann's more generous and, seemingly, more spacious picture. That said, I doubt anyone will be able to correctly identify which was the tangential tracker and which the 9" pivoted tonearm. (I did this experiment once before, with a Thales pivoted tangential tracker and Continuum's 9" Cobra arm; some guessed correctly, but no one knew for certain.

718acorn.chopin

Among the other records I used was pianist Robert Silverman's positively mesmerizing Chopin's Last Waltz, recorded in DSD256 by Ray Kimber (LP, IsoMike 5606). Performance and sound are exquisite. Via the far more expensive rig, Silverman's attacks were somewhat more precise, the piano's sustain better connected to the instrument and more easily delineated from the generous room sound. This put the image of the piano in greater relief and focus.

Through the Bergmann rig, the piano sounded slightly softer and somewhat less focused, its soundboard blending in somewhat with the room reverb. Don't get me wrong—without something far more expensive to compare it to, the Bergmann's overall performance provided me with months of pleasure with every musical genre.

718acorn.clash

It had been years since I'd played the UK version of The Clash (LP, CBS 82000), and my memories of its sound were pretty meek compared to what I heard through the Bergmann and Continuum. Yes, the drums, particularly the cymbals, were nicely recorded, but I hadn't realized how deep the stage was, or how well focused in three dimensions were the voices, often arranged in clusters. My reference rig delivered greater delineation of those clusters, but the Bergmanns' reproduction of them was equally entertaining and engagingly slammin'.

Abruptly switching gears, I played the Electric Recording Company's reissue of Bruckner's Symphony 8 on two separate LPs, with Carl Schuricht conducting the Vienna Philharmonic (2 LPs, EMI ASD 602 and 603/ERC 033 and 034), originally issued in 1964. I don't know what ERC charged for this edition, which was limited to 99 copies and immediately sold out. It probably was costly, but it must have been a bargain compared to what originals are still selling for. (Last February, a copy went for more than $5000.) Probably some of these records' high value can be accounted for by this recording's sensationally natural instrumental textures and harmonics, and its overall transparency and spaciousness.

The music itself is curious; to me, it sounds like musical tapas—a collection of short, sonically tasty appetizers completely unconnected to each other. But it makes for a great demo record, and it showed off all of the Odin-Galder's qualities of ear-pleasing texture, tonality, and harmonic richness. There's plenty here to like, and nothing to dislike.

Conclusion
In terms of quality of sound and, especially, engineering and build, Bergmann Audio's Odin tonearm and Galder turntable perform way above their total price of $35,700. They sound and perform as well as their appearance suggests.

ARTICLE CONTENTS

COMMENTS
Jack L's picture

Hi

Not my experience, pal.

I was sooo delighted when I first played the Danish-made B&O Beogram 4000 tangential tracking arm belt-driven record player back in 1970s. The first electronically controlled automatic TT in the world back then!!!

Immaculate performance with touch control !

This 12Kg-weight human wonder of art was displayed in the New York Musium of Modern Arts (MoMA) in 1973 !!!

Jack L

Sneaky Pete's picture

I cannot speak highly enough of the Galder / Odin combination. The way I frame it is that the combination just gets out of the way and lets the music (LP) speak for itself. It sounds lovely.

I thought I would hear the vacuum/pump, but not at all. I put my ear on the box producing the vacuum & pump and hear nothing. Nothing! I cannot hear any, even slight motor noise once it gets up to speed. I hear the motor winding up, but when it gets to the correct speed - dead quiet. My table rotates perfectly at 33.33 RPMs. Once it clocked in at 33.34 RPMs. No biggie.

I play a variety of LPs dating back to those purchased in high school (1970’s) to current audiophile 45RPM releases and they all sound beautiful. After a good ultrasonic cleaning, even my LPs that have been played since those early days sound superb.

I was skeptical at first, but when I auditioned the Galder/Odin combination at my local audio dealer, I was sold. It sounds even better on my system at home. I auditioned many, many turntables over the past few years and nothing has sounded so lovely. Even those with similar price tags just don’t have to look, feel and sound.

I will also agree, it is a piece of art. The craftsmanship is outstanding.

I love this (my) turntable & arm.

X