Columns Retired Columns & Blogs |
Great review, sounds like a super low real estate solution. Please advise on the QKore6--how do you allocate your 8 boxes across its 6 inputs? Thanks
The line input impedance is specified as 22k ohms. The single-ended impedance was 11k ohms at 20Hz and 1kHz and 6.2k ohms at 20kHz, and the balanced input impedance was 44k ohms at 20Hz and 1kHz, 23k ohms at 20kHz. The single-ended output impedance was the specified 50 ohms across the audioband; the balanced output impedance was 96 ohms, again at all audio frequencies. The line frequency response was flat up to 30kHz into 100k ohms and 600 ohms (fig.12), gently rolling off above that frequency to reach 3dB at 200kHz, as specified. The very close channel balance and the overall response were preserved at lower settings of the volume control.
Channel separation was superbly high, at >130dB in both directions below 2kHz and still 110dB at the top of the audioband. The wideband, unweighted signal/noise ratio, taken with either the balanced or unbalanced inputs shorted to ground and the volume control set to its maximum, was a superb 99.3dB ref. 2V in both channels. This ratio improved to 113.2dB when the measurement bandwidth was restricted to the audioband, and to 116dB when A-weighted. Fig.13 shows the spectrum of the Moon 891's balanced low-frequency noisefloor at 2V with the volume control set to its maximum. The level of random noise is extremely low, and there are no power supplyrelated spuriae visible in this graph.
Fig.14 plots how the THD+noise percentage in the Moon 891's balanced output varies with output voltage into 100k ohms. The downward slope of the traces indicates that the distortion lies below the noise up to 4V. Our usual definition of clipping is when the THD+N reaches 1%; however, the Moon's balanced output seemed to be limited to 12.1V, when the THD was 0.045%. The 891 behaved very similarly into 600 ohms, and with the single-ended output into both impedances.
Fig.15 shows how the THD+N percentage changed with frequency at 4V into 100k ohms (blue, red traces) and 600 ohms (green, gray traces). The distortion into both impedances is extraordinarily low, with only a slight rise below 100Hz. As with the digital inputs, the second harmonic was the highest in level, but even into 600 ohms lay at 106dB (0.0005%; fig.16). Intermodulation distortion was also superbly low in level (fig.17).
One of the Moon 891's unbalanced line inputs can be turned into an MC- or MM-compatible phono input. As another reviewer will be auditioning the phono stage, I examined its measured performance in both MM and MC modes. To minimize noise, I connected a wire from one of the Audio Precision's ground terminals to the grounding lug on the Moon's rear panel.
Out of the box, while the MC input impedance and gain were correctly set to 100 ohms and 60dB, the MM input impedance was set to 10 ohms and the gain to 66dB. Using the front-panel buttons and menu, I reset these parameters to the recommended 47k ohms and 40dB. The MM input impedance was 42k ohms at 20Hz, 39k ohms at 1kHz, and 32k ohms at 20kHz. The MC mode's input impedance was 103 ohms from 20Hz to 20kHz. In Variable mode, the MM input's maximum gain at 1kHz was 50.1dB from the balanced and unbalanced outputs. In Fixed mode, the gain was 40.3dB from both outputs. The MC input's maximum gain was 68.1dB in Variable mode and 58.4dB in Fixed mode, again from both output types. Both input types preserved absolute polarity at the balanced and unbalanced outputs.
The phono input's RIAA correction (fig.18) was well matched between the channels and extremely accurate. The ultrasonic response was down by just 1dB at 100kHz. Channel separation was superb, at 100dB in both directions across the audioband. The MM mode's wideband, unweighted S/N ratio, ref. 1kHz at 5mV, assessed at the balanced output with the inputs shorted to ground and the volume control set to the maximum, was an excellent 87.7dB in both channels. Restricting the measurement bandwidth to 22Hz 22kHz increased the ratio by 2dB, while inserting an A-weighting filter resulted in a ratio of 93.5dB. These ratios were taken with the gain set to 40dB. Resetting the gain to 60dB reduced the ratios by 20dB. The MC mode's S/N ratios, ref. 1kHz at 500µV and with 60dB gain, were less good, at 51dB (wideband), 52dB (audioband), and 56.75dB (A-weighted). To get the lowest noise from the Moon 891's phono input, the gain should not be set too high. Spectral analysis of the MM input's low-frequency noisefloor indicated that no supply-related spuriae were present.
To be sure I wasn't prematurely clipping the preamplifier's output, I examined the phono input's overload margins with the volume control set to "Fixed." Both the MM input's and MC mode's margins were impressively high from 20Hz to 20kHz, at 22.3dB ref. 1kHz at 5mV and 24dB ref. 1kHz at 500µV, respectively. Even with an input around 10dB below the 1kHz overload level, the only distortion harmonic present was the second, at an inconsequential 100dB (0.001%, fig.19). The levels of the intermodulation products with an equal mix of 19 and 20kHz tones were similarly negligible (fig.20).
The measured performance of the Moon 891 is state-of-the-art for both analog and digital inputs!John Atkinson
The Nordost QKore, which comes in three iterations, is a passive grounding device. At this point, I only connect it to one of my components. But that may change down the line after I make modifications to my room treatment. Please check out the explanation on their website.
Thanks, Jason. I should have been more clear. I have a QKore 6 and a QBase already. They are terrific, but I am sometimes capacity constrained with the QKore able to handle only 5 components in addition to the QBase. As you mentioned 8 boxes and only one QKore, I was thinking you had a way to increase the single QKore capacity with Y cables or similar.
Of course, now I wonder why you have not plugged in 5 of the components, and why room treatments would change the value of passive grounding? I have not checked each of my components in isolation for QKore effect, and (due to spouse acceptance factor) I do not have room treatments. But a couple of times while reconfiguring wires in general, QKore wires have come undone and there was an immediate change in sound.
Cheers
... sufficient satisfaction listening to music via the $ 5,499 "superb" NAD M66, or would using the $25K "state-of-the-art" Moon 891 result in five times the enjoyment, even though the 891 lacks a room correction function?
https://www.stereophile.com/content/nad-m66-streaming-preamplifier
My thoughts precisely, as the similarly full-featured NAD measures well and has met with positive listening reviews. The room correction software would be the killer feature for me, as my listening space is less than perfect (as most people’s is). The Moon gear looks fantastic, but I have to think the NAD is within reach of many more readers without unlimited budgets.
A/B vs. D. Moon 891 made in Canada vs. NAD Made in China. A 50 lb. Moon vs. a 16.7 lb NAD. I would say that the NAD may sound really nice FOR THE MONEY, but someone with Jason's ability to differentiate and hear nuance (in music as well as audio) would hear the difference. Build quality, quality of parts and amplifier technology. This is not a knock on NAD equipment which has always punched above its weight. Impossible to say whether it's worth 5x the amount. It is worth that to the person that wants it and can pay for it and hear the difference. I stand by the belief that Jason would feel it was worth it because one would sound better. Superb measurements are not the final arbiter as we all know.
... Moon preamp versus those in the NAD?
What percentage of the electronic components in the Moon preamp are made in Canada?
But we are talking about Canadian labor and something that is not mass produced and an artisanal product. The MOON weighs 3 times as much so if you are paying by the pound it is worth it (joke.)Honestly I don’t have too much invested in this discussion but it does seem like one product is more robustly constructed. But then again, all the people who love their featherweight class D watt monsters would say that doesn’t matter. Everyone’s mileage may vary.