RJR's "Follow-Up" review of the Audio Valve Eclipse line preamplifier was a nice read. I'm sure that it sounds as good as stated. RJR's reviews are always fun to read; I appreciate the depth of his musical knowledge and the diversity of music used in his reviews.

However, does RJR really consider "I Saw Her Standing There" to be the (in his own words) "best punk-rock tune ever written"? This is a joke, right?

Bob, what about this song makes it "punk-rock"?

Perhaps we define punk-rock differently.

Thanks for your response.