rrstesiak
rrstesiak's picture
Offline
Last seen: 4 years 8 months ago
Joined: Mar 22 2015 - 5:38am
Amplifier or Integrated for Magnepan MMG's
bierfeldt
bierfeldt's picture
Offline
Last seen: 2 years 1 month ago
Joined: Oct 26 2007 - 2:30pm

Those speakers have a 4ohm impedance which means they are hard to drive. You need to get an amplifier that is rated for a 2ohm impedances and not every amp can do that. I would encourage you to look at NAD as they are very good at dealing with low impedance speakers or Parasound.

If you want just a power amp, consider the NAD C 275 BEE at $1299 or the Parasound Halo A23. I believe your Creek unit has Pre-amp outs so you could easily one to your existing system.

Neither company publishes a 2ohm rating that I can find but NAD has a portion of their site dedicated to explaining their ratings and they are explicit that they can handle speakers at a 2 ohm impedance. Parasound's Halo line carries a THX certification and being able to handle a 2 ohm impedance is part of the THX testing.

rrstesiak
rrstesiak's picture
Offline
Last seen: 4 years 8 months ago
Joined: Mar 22 2015 - 5:38am

bierfeldt:

I am familiar with NAD's vintage stuff and even own a 7140 Integrated...

And this very amp, the 275 BEE, came up in another recommendation as it's also bridgeable from what I know should I decide to even get another one in the further future.. excellent suggestion. I didn't even think to just send the creek out to a raw amp. It's funny when common sense is missed sometimes. And the price is also fair. Thank you.I've heard good things from parasound..but for me I've never auditioned any of their offerings and know very little..I am at least familiar with NAD as being decent and known as powerful for AMPS. I have no idea if the new NAD stuff is very good.. do you know if they produce a deep and wide soundstage? My Creek seems very good at wide, but it's soundstage is not very deep. But that could also be from my PS Audio NuWave DAC...it's hard to get synergy.

I would *love* to get the Musical Fidelity M6PRX; as I've heard outstanding reviews on it's integrated "cousin" as having very deep and wide soundstage...but it's out of my price range significantly.

Any other recommendations welcome...it will be a month or three before I can afford to upgrade the amp.

bierfeldt
bierfeldt's picture
Offline
Last seen: 2 years 1 month ago
Joined: Oct 26 2007 - 2:30pm

I have listened to the NAD C 275 BEE paired with an NAD C 165BEE. One of my local dealers uses that combo to drive speakers in their showroom.

I spent quite a bit of time listening to it when I was auditioning speakers for my home theatre. I bought the Sunfire HRS line for my 7.1 channel after listening to them driven by the NAD equipemnt. I found the NAD to be detailed, a hair warm and in that showroom, it had a deep 3 dimensional sound. What I am not sure about is how much of that is the NAD power amp or the Sunfire speakers. .

Because NAD does not have a balanced pre/pro or power amp in the sub $3K range, I did not consider them seriously when I was looking to power my home theatre. I have a personal bias in favor of balanced equipment which I am not entirely sure is rational.

I went out and seriously demo'd the Parasound Halo equipment. The Halo line is balanced and I seriously considered Parasound Halo P5 with the Halo A23 for my 2.1 system. Parasound was more neutral to me than the NAD. Still very detailed but lacked that touch of warmth. Ultimately, I just don't need 125w of power to drive my Revels and settled for a Rega Brio R for $1350 less and don't regret the decision.

The one other wild card would be to look for something vintage. I really like the Carver TFM-35CB. It has more power than you need, but it is a mind bogglingly good sounding power amp and you could probably pick one up that has been refurbed for $500 to $600.

commsysman
commsysman's picture
Offline
Last seen: 2 years 4 months ago
Joined: Apr 4 2006 - 11:33am
rrstesiak wrote:

Any suggestions on an integrated or amp for Magnepan MMG? Price IS an object; need to keep it under $2,000. I currently have a Creek Evolution 50A integrated at the core of my system and do like it.

Mostly, I am looking for solid state as opposed to tube; and I am also interested in someone's experience with the MMG's and what wattage they really need to perform optimally. The Magnepan website unfortunately was of absolute no help in suggestion wattage .

Thanks In Advance,

Ron

The Arcam A28 amplifier would be my first choice for plenty of power and great sound quality.

I see it at Magnolia for $1700.

The Musical Fidelity M6 integrated is significantly better, but it is $7000; it should be!

I use the Musical Fidelity M6PRX amplifier to drive my Vandersteen Treos, and it is excellent-sounding. I drive it with an Audio Research LS26 preamp.

You would have to spend 3 to 4 times as much money for a tube amp in the class you would need.

rrstesiak
rrstesiak's picture
Offline
Last seen: 4 years 8 months ago
Joined: Mar 22 2015 - 5:38am

commsysman:

I have the Musical Fidelity M6PRX as my "dream amp" one day or it's equivalent.

All:

I'm kind of paralyzed... my budget just took a major hit and so am now looking at a totally different solution and abandoning Magnepans for now. I am instead going to try to get a 3D soundstage with a little more power than my creek 50A for under $1,000.

I have since started a new thread under Amplification called "Crown XLS Pro and Class D Bargains".

Best Regards,

Ron

steveharlos
steveharlos's picture
Offline
Last seen: 3 years 11 months ago
Joined: Aug 28 2015 - 7:53am

I read that Maggies do best with solid state, high output (150 wpc or better) amplifiers. On Audiogon, I purchased a used Marantz PM-94 for $550, and I believe this is a match made in heaven. Similar vintage integrated amps such as McIntosh 6100 or 6200 would probably do just as well.

rrstesiak
rrstesiak's picture
Offline
Last seen: 4 years 8 months ago
Joined: Mar 22 2015 - 5:38am

Steve:

I absolutely love a good vintage find.

On that topic, what is your opinion of the Adcom GFA 555's?

I would buy two for $600-$700, and run them in mono at 600 watts each 8 Ohm, 850 Watts 4 ohm. But they need the fans at those output levels.

Cheers,

Ron

steveharlos
steveharlos's picture
Offline
Last seen: 3 years 11 months ago
Joined: Aug 28 2015 - 7:53am

Haven't ever heard the GFA 555, but Stereophile gave a glowing review back in 1995.I looked at Adcom before I went with the Marantz, and I liked the sound and build quality. Before buying two, I would try one alone to see if it delivers the sound you're after. If not, you can always find a companion. Good luck! Steve

rrstesiak
rrstesiak's picture
Offline
Last seen: 4 years 8 months ago
Joined: Mar 22 2015 - 5:38am

This is now a long-term project, as I recently purchased a Bryston BDA-1 DAC and a Bowers & Wilkins ASW CM10 Sub...exhausting my discretionary funds for now.

I appreciate the vote of confidence for the Adcoms.

A modern amp I like is the NAD C275BEE, at 330 watts per channel bridged mono, and 4 ohm stable.
Two of those would set me back $2600.

Or, I could go with a Musical Fidelity amp or integrated for $3,000 and get 220-230 watts per channel.

These purchases have been pushed back..but any opinions on the newer stuff? Anything you recommend?

Respectfully,

Ron

steveharlos
steveharlos's picture
Offline
Last seen: 3 years 11 months ago
Joined: Aug 28 2015 - 7:53am

You can't go wrong with either one. I have heard and liked both, so it's really up to your listening preferences. In that price range, I'd check out HK 990, Peachtree Audio nova125SE, or Audio Research. I just saw a used ARC VT-60 on ebay for $1695.

bierfeldt
bierfeldt's picture
Offline
Last seen: 2 years 1 month ago
Joined: Oct 26 2007 - 2:30pm

Adcom is solid but unspectacular. They make a high quality amp that delivers a lot of power at the expense of fine detail. TheyAdcoms are very much like the Parasound Halo A21 and A23. It won't offend you and sound awful but it won't wow you either. Your Creek is a more refined product, just with a lower power output. If you want to take a step forward both in power and detail, you are going to want to pass on Adcom.

The NAD amps you are considering are closer to even in quality vs. your Creek but will only be step forward in power output. You would be better served getting the Bryston power amp you have been looking at. If I was comfortable with used gear, personally, I would buy a used Ayre V-5xe which I saw on Audiogon for $2500. It may not have the monstrous power output of some of these others, but it cleanly doubles its output as impedance is halved. 300w into 4ohms. And the level of refinement is in a completely different league compared to Adcom or NADs BEE series.

For new equipment, you would be much better served waiting and getting a Musical Fidelity M6 or a Rogue Audio Medusa at $3500 or $4K respectively.

bierfeldt
bierfeldt's picture
Offline
Last seen: 2 years 1 month ago
Joined: Oct 26 2007 - 2:30pm

Accidental double post

rrstesiak
rrstesiak's picture
Offline
Last seen: 4 years 8 months ago
Joined: Mar 22 2015 - 5:38am

Now that I have some signifiant time, I like the idea of going for the Ayre on Audiogon. I believe you, as you are an Ayre owner, that it will elevate my sound. To me, that is the most compelling.

If come purchase time I cannot find a decent used Ayre, anything new you could recommend that would be a step above the NAD C275BEE?

Respectfully,

Ron

ps. the CM series B&W sub is to DIE for. Very articulate and controlled when needed, and hits my chest on Dance/Dub Step/House/Acid. It also really fills out a jazz drum kit. Buddy Rich sounds like his kit is in my living room. just a very lucky purchase; as not many people own this thing which is probably due to it's price or the simple fact B&W cm series put out very good bass. But it is a CM series through and through. and weighs a ton.

bierfeldt
bierfeldt's picture
Offline
Last seen: 2 years 1 month ago
Joined: Oct 26 2007 - 2:30pm

IMO, you still need to decide on speakers first. If there is one thing I learned in my most recent purchase, equipment in this price range is far from neutral. With an eye toward Maggies only:

The NAD Master Series M22 at $3K - 250w of power and for Class D, they are licensing an elite Class D module called nCore. This is a great sounding power amp and blows the C275BEEs out of the water.

Musical Fidelity M6 PRX at $3500 - I believe you are familiar.

Rogue Audio Medusa at $4K - 200w into 8ohms, 400w into 4ohms with their exclusive Tube D technology. It requires effort to find the right preamp but this line gets The Absolute Sound Editor's Choice award for a reason. Stereophile hasn't reviewed it but I am certain it would get an A rating. The Hydra, which is what I have is 100w/200w into 8ohms and 4ohms and is $3K.

After really digging and trying to find exceptional values, these three are the least expensive power amps I can find that I think are real stand outs. Honestly, it is easy to find $8K or $10K power amps that sound great. These are the few, elite modestly priced amps.

rrstesiak
rrstesiak's picture
Offline
Last seen: 4 years 8 months ago
Joined: Mar 22 2015 - 5:38am

All:

If ANYONE KNOWS REAL WORLD AMP STATS THAT MAGNEPAN SPEAKERS NEED, PLEASE REPLY!!

Here is a serious quote from their own website on the topic:

Magnepan wrote:

Personal tastes are "all over the map". We hear of customers that are perfectly happy with 50 watts and others using 1000 watts.

Leaving me totally clueless.

bierfeldt:

As for speakers, I have made my decision to definitely go Magnepan...especially since the successful purchase of a very good subwoofer. That was my only remaining worry with the more entry level Maggies...I know they need a sub...and I did not have a good one until recently. I just wish someone could tell me the raw specs and power required for the various models!

I also think buying a raw amp over a powerful integrated at these power levels is a cost savings.

Having said that,
I did find a Bryston 3BSST2...which I won't go older than that in used gear..for $2200...(150W 8 ohm, 250W into 4 ohm...is bridgeable.)..But i really want the 4BSST2 if I were to go Bryston. (it is literally double the power..

As for the others, please don't get upset when I say for NOW, I want to stay away from anything that is Class D. For my B&W sub, it's fine. But I am really skeptical as an Electrical Engineer...as I am very well versed with the high-frequncy switching that goes on in the Class D topology.

Having said that, NAD are excellent engineers and I may trust their design in their Master Series... that is amazing to me! But I again fear too expensive.

I basically have a $2000 high mark.. possibly a little higher, but unless I really wait a long time, nowhere near $3000.

Come to think of it, I also can't fault Rogue Audio and I do trust them... it's just maybe the EE in me being too skeptical. But alas, they are too far out of reach as well anyway.

So that leaves me with in order of preference:

1. A used Bryston 3BSST2 or with a little luck a 4BSST2.
2. possibly Ayre V-5xe used
3. NAD C275BEE... can be bridged, mono...so could buy one, upgrade to two if needed. The most budget friendly.
4. possibly Parasound A21. I think for Maggies the A23 is not enough power.

I wish I knew more about Parasound... I have heard nothing but good things about Ayre being very premium...and I have auditioned NAD products as well as Bryston. SO the only brand I am not familiar with at all is Parasound... but I know they get nothing but good press so I think these four are my short list.

Cheers,

Ron

bierfeldt
bierfeldt's picture
Offline
Last seen: 2 years 1 month ago
Joined: Oct 26 2007 - 2:30pm

I would reach out and spend some time talking to a Maggie dealer. Reality is, listening volume matters as doessize of room. All speakers will open up with the right amount of power and I have no idea what amount of power is required for Maggies. I do know that my Ayre dealer sells Maggies and demos them with that Ayre v-5xe amp and he said it shows them off very well. Incidentally, that is why I thought of it for you.

My Ayre dealer is also a Parasound dealer and they have the P5 and Halo A23 on display and use it to drive their bookshelf speakers. I asked about the A21 when I was nervous about the Rogue and the conclusion is it is nice but unspectacular. You will not step forward in quality, only power. The real gems in Parasounds line are the JC-1,2 and 3+.

Here is another thought and is how I got killer prices on the Rogue and Ayre units I bought. Hunt down a floor model. Most retailers like to turn their floor models over every 12 to 18 months and will usually give you 20-30% off and the manufacturer treats it like it's a new so full warranty. This is no help for an Ayre amp, but could help out with Musical Fidelity or Bryston.

Regarding class D, I got it. I am technically far from being an expert and I know nothing about why it works or doesn't work so you aren't going to offend me. I just listen and buy the amp I like the best and have heard several class Ds that I think are exceptional. Ignorance is bliss and for me, it is all about the sound. The reason they keep popping up though is that they don't need the monstrous power supplies and heat sink of class A or even A/B and just cost less to make. Unfortunately, really great class A or A/B units just seem to cost more.

In fairness, until about a year ago, I thought all class Ds were crap with the exception of Peachtree. The first really exceptional Class D I heard was Peachtree Nova 220. What a monster of a power amp for $1000 and it sounds fantastic. If it came out today, they would probably sell a ton of them. Three years ago they struggled to move them at all. The market just wasn't ready yet.

bierfeldt
bierfeldt's picture
Offline
Last seen: 2 years 1 month ago
Joined: Oct 26 2007 - 2:30pm

Kudos to commsysman for pointing this one out.

If I was going to roll the dice on a non-class D amp that is below $3500, I would probably try out a Vincent. The Vincent SP-331 is $1299 from Upscale Audio and the SP-331MK which won Absolute Sounds Editor's Choice award is $2499. These are well designed amps with the 311MK giving you Class A output for the first 10w while power output doubles as impedance is halved with its monstrous 1000w power supply.

Additionally, the Hybrid design would likely meld really well with a Solid State preamp like the Musical Fidelity M6. The tube based inputs on the Vincent would help soften to forwardness that you will get from a solid state preamp.

For $5K brand new, that would not be an easy combination to beat. Additionally, the internal phono stage on that Musical Fidelity is going to be similar to slightly better than the Vincent you currently have. I was told that to beat it, you will need to step up to the Musical Surroundings Phonomena II which is $650.

Log in or register to post comments
-->
  • X