I was at the early set on Saturday and I thought that Motion's playing was obnoxious. I kept punching at his ride cymbal with a flat stick making it very hard to hear what Hersch is doing and I was sitting at the second table behind Hersch. I'm tired of critics talking about how great Motion is. He comps with no regard for the dynamics of the people he's playing with, to say nothing about the audiences ability to hear the other musicians on the stand.
Fred Hersch, Drew Gress, Paul Motian
I’ve dropped my jaw enough times in this space about Motian’s magicianship. Many drummers accent the beat by playing around it, but Motian—who’s nearly 79 and more agile than ever—stretches and squeezes time a half-dozen ways in every 8-bar phrase, always startling but never out of place, like nobody since Tony Williams.
Gress, a regular in Hersch’s early bands who hangs more in avant-garde circles now, hovered close to the songs’ lines, but he flitted from one line to another—melodic, harmonic, or a cruising bass walk—with inventive ease and a nice, fat tone.
But it was Hersch who raised eyebrows and sparked delight, infusing whatever he played—standards, blues, bossas, original compositions, or Monk tunes—with a wizard’s imagination and a lyrical intensity.
The trio plays through Sunday. If you can’t make it, pick up his latest solo CD, Fred Hersch Plays Jobim (on the Sunnyside label), in which he covers the Brazilian classics with dynamic subtlety, great verve, romantic flourish, and not a trace of sentimentalism.
- Login or register to post comments
| Loudspeakers Amplification Digital Sources | Analog Sources Accessories Featured | Music Columns Features | Show Reports | Show Reports |
Recommended Components Blogs Latest News Community |
Shop Resources Subscriptions |



