MBL 111B loudspeaker Measurements part 2
Fig.6 MBL 111B, vertical response family at 50", normalized to response on 43"-high listening axis, from back to front: differences in response 15 degrees-5 degrees above axis, reference response, differences in response 5 degrees-10 degrees below axis.
Fig.7 shows the spatially averaged response of the MBL 111Bs in my listening room. This kind of graph always reveals a nice correlation with a speaker's perceived balance, and fig.7 is no exception. The midrange is astonishingly flat, the bass is extended without being exaggerated in level, the low treble is a little recessed, and the penultimate octave peaks slightly—all exactly as I heard in my auditioning!
Fig.7 MBL 111B, spatially averaged, 1/3-octave, freefield response in JA's listening room.
With its grille on, the 111B's impulse response (not shown) is obscured by high-frequency reflections from the perforated metal. Even with the integrating effect of the step response (fig.8), the strongest grille reflection can be seen as a discontinuity about 0.8ms after the tweeter step. Note also that, despite the physical setback of the higher-frequency drive-units, the use of a high-order crossover means that the 111B is not time-coherent (not that that really matters).
Fig.8 MBL 111B, on-axis step response at 50" (5ms time window, 30kHz bandwidth).
Fig.9 shows the MBL 111B's cumulative spectral-decay or waterfall plot with the grille in place. Note how ragged and hashy the sound decay appears in the top two audio octaves. This is due to the reflections of the sound from the grille. While I'm sure these occur too soon after the main arrival of the sound to be perceived as individual events, I'm also sure that the time-smearing of the treble energy results in the somewhat disappointing sound I heard from the speaker until I removed the grille. Fig.10 is a similar graph taken without the grille. You can see how much cleaner the entire treble region appears, though there is still a residual mode apparent just below 7kHz.
Fig.9 MBL 111B, cumulative spectral-decay plot with grille on at 50" (0.15ms risetime).
Fig.10 MBL 111B, cumulative spectral-decay plot with grille off at 50" (0.15ms risetime).
Finally, fig.11 shows the alteration to the MBL's on-axis frequency response. Obviously, the grille is the source of all the peaks and dips seen in the treble in fig.4. The speaker looks drop-dead gorgeous with the grille in place, but you need to remove it to get the sound quality you've paid for.—John Atkinson
Fig.11 MBL 111B, effect of speaker grille on on-axis frequency response, normalized to response without grille (5dB/vertical div.).