Would you like Stereophile's reviews to include power-draw measurements?

Would you like <I>Stereophile</I>'s reviews to include power-draw measurements?
Yes, very important
44% (137 votes)
Yes, somewhat important
35% (109 votes)
Don't care
14% (45 votes)
No, leave them out
7% (23 votes)
Total votes: 314

Cars rate energy use as miles per gallon (MPG), but what about audio equipment? Reader "wook" wants to know: "Would you like <I>Stereophile</I>'s reviews to include power-draw measurements?"

Share | |
COMMENTS
Kevin L's picture

It would be good to know, probably more important to know what the power draw in standby is, when the equipment is not in use.

KR's picture

I would like to see this from now on.

dougy kilowatt's picture

It would be nice to have the information. At least it would cause people to give a little thought to the power consumption of their gear. I doubt many do now.

Bob's picture

It's long overdue.

S.  Chapman's picture

Yes, power draw measurements are very important, especially when the equipment is supposedly turned off. When are manufacturers going to learn that we can no longer afford to have their products constantly using electricity? That's one of the things I especially like about most tube gear: when it's off, it's really off.

Carter's picture

It would also be helpful to know how much power is drawn when the equipment is off, as these days many items aren't actually turned off but rather put into a low power standby mode.

Paul Mindemann's picture

There is a movement in every other major manufacturing category toward making things with less of an impact on the environment. Why should high-end audio be any different?

Doug Credille's picture

Please do.

Stephen Curling's picture

I think a power draw spec would valuable when testing amps or powered subwoofers, especially the kW class amps (Krell Master Reference Amp comes to mind) or any Class D product.

Jorge's picture

It's a must. Power has been a critical factor in selecting equipment for me.

George Henschke's picture

More important for high power items like amps than for lower power items like CD players. Standby power also good to know.

Robert_S's picture

We should consider the welfare of the planet, for future generations.

Rich's picture

A no-brainer.

Plattier Jean-Paul from France's picture

By this time of global warming and energy shortage, it is a very important criterion. And also, and maybe more important for my (our)satisfaction, high sensitivity speakers and low power or good Class D amps can be more pleasant and accurate to my ears than hyper expensive and power pumping solid state powerhouses (these last ones are definitely dinosaurs, still good and impressive maybe, but condemned to shortly disappear.

John M from Mid-Mo's picture

Most of the time, manufacturer specifications provide power consumption. What really matters (if you're into that sort of thing), is effeciency. Inefficiency is directly proportional to the radiated heat. Generally, tubed components and cetainly class A amps are inefficient while class AB, B and D are more efficient. That being said, people who purchase tubed or class A components aren't doing so for the efficiency and power consumption would be a useless number. Of course, you'd also have to consider the practice of leaving the component "on" 24/7 and factor that into your power draw equation... Unless the manufacturer specifications for power consuption are vastly different from measurements, the measurement will be superfluous (in addition to being useless). This is sort of like trying to ensure the claimed MPG ratings on things like Hummers, Ferraris and Abrams Tanks are accurate...vehicles like these aren't purchased for efficiency. I use Monster AVS 2000's for the home theater and main stereo rig. If you use a component like this, you see the instantaneous current draw (and this is what we pay for...it is suprising how much current is drawn by my 42 inch LCD in comparison to the Classe' CA-301). If Wook is truly interested, he should purchase a similar item and multiply (voltage X amperage = watts). Watts X time(hours)/1000=kilowatt-hours.

Noah Bickart's picture

Why not? Especially for those fools who insist on leaving their equipment on all the time, wasting precious energy for a placebo effect

Haroon Chaudrey's picture

It is a must. It will help me to choose a power filtering device and also help me weigh the calim of some so called "Class A" amplifiers.

Nick's picture

It is no longer acceptable to have a high power amp that is always on with a high power draw. Hifi needs to get green before audiophiles are tagged as wasting energy instead of just money.

Paul Basinski's picture

Trust your ears and listen. Good cables in the right system can definitely improve the sound.

WSE3's picture

Might be the deciding factor among otherwise equal products, analog power amps in particular.

Pages

X
Enter your Stereophile.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
Loading