Quote:
Hats off to John Atkinson!

Thank you.

Quote:
From the review I got the impression that in absolute sense, Mark Levinson No.380S is little dark than absolute neutral, Parasound Halo JC 2 is little bright than absolute neutral and Simaudio Moon Evolution P7 hangs in between but leaning more toward JC 2.

That's correct, but I could live with each of these 3 line preamps.

Quote:
What is the absolute neutral for preamplifier for you? Your memory of live recordings that you did or another preamplifier (say Ayre KX-R for which you gave an impression that it was another class)?

Yes, the Ayre KX-R combines the best aspects of each of these preamps, though it is significantly more expensive, of course. What astonished me about the Ayre was that it sounded better than a straightwire bypass!!!!

John Atkinson
Editor, Stereophile

Don't forget brands that Stereophile is unlikely to review, like Rowland's Capri preamp. Stereophile's coverage give limited to no exposure to some brands like Rowland, Playback Designs, etc.

If you're going to buy without listening, then, by all means, rely on Stereophile. They're one of the best overall sources, but if you've got ears and listen for yourself, then expand your horizons.

Dave

Amen...nothing I own has been in stereophile, and I couldnt be happier. stereophile covers a very, very small portion of what is out there...

Quote:
Don't forget brands that Stereophile is unlikely to review, like Rowland's Capri preamp. Stereophile's coverage give limited to no exposure to some brands like Rowland, Playback Designs, etc.

If you're going to buy without listening, then, by all means, rely on Stereophile. They're one of the best overall sources, but if you've got ears and listen for yourself, then expand your horizons.

Dave