You are here

Log in or register to post comments
Jonzie
Jonzie's picture
Offline
Last seen: Never ago
Joined: Oct 23 2007 - 1:26am
B&W 802d with NAD Master Series or Lyngdorf TDA 2200/CD1?

I HAVE A DREAM (and a dilemma) :-)

First a little background:

As a student and have a limited income, but have got a fair price for my old surround system, changing to stereo now. But my pocket doesn't contain limited depths.

For the new system, I have decided to focus on the speakers as the main and heavy part of the setup (and economy) and buy an amp/player, that, while not being completely up to the price/performance standard of the speakers, will get the job done within certain sense.

I have made the decision to purchase a couple of B&W 802d's. - A dream long time coming. I love the transparency and dynamics of them. And they almost look as sexy as my girlfriend:-)

But I am still puzzled in reference to the other side of the coin. How should I fuel the 802's? - As it is right now, I have two options. I have got a sweet offer on the NAD M3/M5 (Master Series) as well as the Lyngdorf TDA2200/CD1. But what to chose...

As of now, I have only listened to the NAD setup. It sounds very good. It seems to have a lot of power for the money (2x180w dual mono) and have a nice sense of detail. It also has a presence that I find engaging.
However, it does not seem have some of the forwardness and punch in the overall frequency spectrum that I would like to get out of the 802d's (in a perfect world).

I have read the review from Michael Fremer, which was reassuring in many ways. But as many other HiFi enthusiasts, I want perfection as the trees calmly grow into the sky:-)

- I am not a laid back listener. I like to have a detail-filled sound with a slightly forward image.

This leads to the alternative which is the Lyngdorf TDA2200/CD1. From my readings and suggestions from friends, the TDA2200 should have an insane amount of correctness and detail from the direct digital pathway between the player and amp (for the price). But is should also lack some "presence" and personality of analogous amps, as the sound has the potential to become too analytical.

I am generally analytical in my listening attitude and like to go "hiking" in the sound-scape, as I have a musical background as well as a great love for auditory spaces and definition (as all you other guys do as well, I suppose:-D).
That is the reason why I am interested in the TDA2200, as I have the feeling it will be a spectacular provider of detail and spark - especially within the budget.

So:

Does anyone have an opinion on this matter? Perhaps a subjective comparison of the NAD M3/M5 setup vs. the Lyngdorf if possible? However, an assessment of the two individually will be very much appreciated, of course! :-D

For instance, my experience tells me that NAD amps are very power efficient, bringing LOTS of muscles pr. watt, which is a VERY good thing in reference to 802d's. But is it enough? And how does the 2x200w TDA2200 compare to power of the 2x180w PD (powerdrive) of the NAD M3?

As previously mentioned, I only have the money to chose from these two, so hopefully, they will be sufficient...

Thank you in advance, if you have even read this far, I appreciate it:-D

Best regards,

Jonzie

jgill1976
jgill1976's picture
Offline
Last seen: Never ago
Joined: Oct 16 2007 - 7:25pm
Re: B&W 802d with NAD Master Series or Lyngdorf TDA 2200/CD1

Why not just get the RB-1080 amp and RC-1082 by Rotel. I'm not sure the prices on them, but they can't be that bad. Besides, B&W and Rotel are pretty much made to go together.

Jonzie
Jonzie's picture
Offline
Last seen: Never ago
Joined: Oct 23 2007 - 1:26am
Re: B&W 802d with NAD Master Series or Lyngdorf TDA 2200/CD1

Hey thanks for the council!

Prob is, that these setups are available for me at a bargain price so it is pretty much the choice I have...

I would probably be best off with a setup that was sonically in between the two, but it is simply not possible at this stage. Next time, perhaps:-)

  • X
    Enter your Stereophile.com username.
    Enter the password that accompanies your username.
    Loading