Would you ever create and use a DIY component in your system?

Audio continues to host a healthy Do-It-Yourself (DIY) market. Folks build everything from components to wire to speaker systems. Has the DIY bug bitten you?

Would you ever create and use a DIY component in your system?
Never
13% (44 votes)
I might, if I had the time and know-how
26% (89 votes)
DIY, while cost-effective, can't compete with the major brands
4% (13 votes)
Yes, I have a DIY component (or two)
58% (198 votes)
Total votes: 344

COMMENTS
Anonymous's picture

amp.sp

fokus's picture

Infinitely more fun and more value than traditional right-wing manufactured components

hifiZen's picture

My entire system's DIY, and (IMHO) it outdoes most commercial products, especially since I can custom-tailor each piece of equipment to my preferences.

Kye's picture

Most of my system is DIY. It is the second best system I have ever heard, and the best system is over 50 times more expensive. :)

M_Anker's picture

Diy can sound as good as or better than commercial products. DIY upgrade boards can make your commercial products sound twice a good. Without DIY doing all your research for you, half the commercial products would not be available!

David Toatley's picture

Everyone has different aspects of the hobby they enjoy. I enjoy, like most, tweaking my system to get the best presentation possible. DIY affords you in some cases to determine whether a product is bunk or legitimate. DIY also lets you get that "Proud Papa Syndrome" when it works. The same is true of some one who takes the time and energy to research a purchase. Just different approaches to the same goal: Great Sound.

RP Michigan's picture

Had help building it from a techie friend but my tube 12AX7 LPS sounds great for around $450. Looks good, too, and I learned a lot. May try an amp or preamp next time.

Paul Marciniak's picture

In the past, I've built Heath and Dynaco. Most recently, I built the Madisound ODIN, a tremendous speaker and an unbelievable value.

Idler's picture

Have built and/or modified everything with the exception of phono cartridges. It is the most cost effective way to improve one's system. AC power cords and device power supplies can make huge improvements (and to think, they are not "in" the signal path).

Kit Thomas's picture

I've made interconnects, speaker cables, speaker stands, etc. I have also done DIY repairs to electronic components, but I have never attempted a more complicated DIY electronic design/build project; though, that would be fun.

Bob Petersen's picture

I have never bought a speaker, always built them myself.

norman's picture

I would not have the time, skill or patience.

First time speaker builder's picture

I made a DIY subwoofer with little audio engineering experience or woodworking experience. The only thing I did was read a speaker building book and use some free software to calculate the box volume and then order the driver and amplifier from online sources recommended by an email discussion group (Bass list). I thought the sound was OK. I then went to my local electronics store to listen to their subwoofers (JBL, Infinity, Velodyne, etc) and discovered to my surprise how much worse they sounded compared to my DIY. I don't understand it. It must be that the retail units use poor components and crappy box material with subpar craftsmanship. But how could they do it worse than I did and sell them for more?

Doug Wolfe's picture

Cost effective, fun and the results are great!

guy whitney's picture

Sure and I'd be interested to know if Stereophile (or others?) offer reviews or comments on speaker kits. I've done DIY speakers long ago, with fair to poor results, therefore with any future attempts I would completely follow a (hopefully) proven design.

Robin Banks's picture

I have never had the urge to build my own audio component and add it to my system. I'd much rather build the component rack instead.

Dan Arborak's picture

yes, cables, interconects, isolation,and power.

Dimitris Gogas's picture

I once had a DIY amp. It was rather nice with the speakers I had then. Then I upgraded speakers and it ocurred to me that the amp was really rather awful.

johnj @ worldchat.com's picture

speakers speaker cables interconnects cabinetry All work just fine.

jpp's picture

My version of DIY is eBay. Scope what's available in good, older equipment and mix and match. When you're tired of it, you resell it for as much or more than you paid for it. Great way to mix, match and find the best combination of components.

B-A Finlan's picture

Hello! Anyone remember Dynaco?

Raph's picture

I have vague plans to build part of what will become a second system. Of course it will have to wait until the main system is totally sorted.

Geno's picture

If anyone thinks DIY is a way of saving money, think again. You always want to use those $25.00 caps and $50.00 coils. What you do get is fantastic sound and the satisfaction of doing it yourself. Commercial products do have their advantages though. Can you say "remote"?

Bostjan's picture

I am a great vinyl lover and I have actually built my first turntable from ground up. I still use it occasionally because of the specific sound it produces and sounds (at least to my ears) very good with some material (especially acoustic records and light pop). I have also built all of my interconnects and I would not change them for any commecially available interconnects.

Anonymous's picture

Cables so far my only attempt, but I'm intrigued by Linkwitz's speaker designs...

Mike Garner's picture

DIY, while not always the best, does educate the DIY'er on what it takes to build a quality component. It gives one a deeper appreciation for the art of high fidelity.

Chris Garver's picture

Along the line that Sam Tellig says about tweaks, if they're cheap and reversable then feel free to amuse yourself. Personally, I've found my DIY CAT 5 speaker cables to easily better my far more expensive commercial cables.

Don Bilger's picture

If we stretch the definition of "DIY" to include kits, both stock and modified, I have quite a number of DIY components in my audio systems. One of my favorites combines a Dynaco PAT-4 chassis, an Audio by Van Alstine Omega II circuit set, and a thorough re-wiring of the PAT-4's switches to give the preamp the control flexibility I needed for a large system. That preamp, which looks like a bone-stock PAT-4 and sounds high-end, has wiped the condescending smiles off more than a few audiophile faces.

Herv's picture

Yes, I have a DIY component, and I use it every day! Mine is not really cost effective, but does compete with the major brands!

The Enduser's picture

For my money I want someone who builds equipment for a living to make my equipment because I am not an engineer by trade and can not afford all the R&D that goes into the best equipment for sound reproduction. It was fun when I was a Boy Scout and built my first transistor radio, but my attitude is let the pros do their job and I'll do mine.

Pages

X