Should Stereophile cover more vinyl playback products?

With Michael Fremer's "Tracking Angle" column and periodic vinyl product reviews from many others, should <I>Stereophile</I> be doing even more in this area?

Should <I>Stereophile</I> cover more vinyl playback products?
Yes, should cover far more
38% (89 votes)
Yes, should cover a little more
24% (56 votes)
Just about right
18% (43 votes)
No, there is a bit too much already
12% (29 votes)
No, there is way too much already
8% (20 votes)
Total votes: 237

COMMENTS
Just Stop's picture

We're trying to move forward in time here folks, not backwards. Audiophiles' preoccupation with vinyl becomes more and more absurd as times goes by. Stop it, please!

Monica's picture

It's hard to find good vinyl recommendations from someone who really knows music. A magazine such as yourself doing vinyl reviews and write-ups...even better! I will looking for them!

acigarnut's picture

Being new to the vinyl arena, I have to admit that I listen to LPs about 80% of the time over CDs. There are several reasons, but let's bring it to the first two: 1) LPs sound betteron the proper equipment, and 2_ I am tired of the recording industry whining about lack of sales, etc, when it is trying to ram poorly recorded, overhyped, underengineered recordings on us. There is more good music to be had on LPs than I can ever hope to play. Therefore, it would be fantastic to have more analog hardware reviews, as well as possilby reviewing LPs themselves.

Mr.  Manners's picture

Rather than a pithy arguement about why you should, I'll leave it with a simple "Yes, please"

Tim Driskel's picture

Absolutely, with todays hi grade idie releases an occasional pop or click significantly Supersedes the stale analytical soundscape which includes all the digital anomalies such as warble, ghosting, clocking errors (digital skipping), clip instead of roll off and the ever present in your face brightness. Not that I would want Mr. Fremer garnering a larger bed of work but it would be nice to see three or four different staff writers contributing their different views of analog reproduction. I'm sure you have other writers who hold some strong joys of analog even today.

Donald N.'s picture

I'm just being greedy but, I do find additional coverage of analog desirable.

Gerald Neily's picture

There is only one Mikey Fremer, so adding another writer to the vinyl beat would be superfluous.

Byron Worthen's picture

Someone (might have been Michael Fremer) once said (regarding redbook CD resolution vs analogue): "We already have a high-resolution source. It's sampling rate is infinite" I am not going to SACD or DVDA. I have a good CD player, but my serious bucks go to records and record playing gear.

Dino Proctor's picture

There's always room for a bit more coverage of vinyl. I'm currently rediscovering my old turntable and I think my ears and my Sonus Faber Concertos are breathing a sigh of relief after struggling with CD for five years.

David L.  Wyatt jr.'s picture

How many audiophiles can buy vinyl outside of mail order or estate sales?

Tom McGrath's picture

Like it or not, Music and vidio is going digital. Why not cover even more digital playback systems. Ther are a lot of very good ones that Stereophile has not even acknowledged.

Glenn Bennett's picture

It's hard to believe that you guys still think vinyl sounds as good as or better than the best CDs! It's fun to read about new 'tables, but you would be serving readers better to cover various stereo components available at a realistic price than waste pages on vinyl related components we either can't afford or would never buy anyway. Our old LPs may still be fun to listen to sometimes but vinyl is dead! Get over it.

Bill Bostancic's picture

Vinyl is the high-rez stamdard and a high-end magazine needs to cover the best resolution system in depth.

Keith Y's picture

You have a really good balance.

Tim Bishop's picture

While I love vinyl product reviews, to many can be just as bad as to few. The only thing I would really like to see a bit more of are graphs and measurements of cartridges, rumble and wow and flutter of tirntables, and the like.

Doug in MO's picture

Vinyl can sound good, sure, but it survives primarily as a retro aging-boomer pacifier. Digital is the future.

r raz's picture

turntablist dj

Brankin's picture

I think it is just fine as is the rest of your coverage.

Kernith's picture

More vinyl and analog gear reviews!!!! Actually, you should match an analog review for every digital review.

pkf2's picture

it has falling off. Mikey does a good job, but needs more space to cover lps on thier own.

Postal Grunt's picture

Even if I have no immediate intention of upgrading my vinyl playback gear, I do try to find some of the music mentioned in the articles.

C.  Isaacs's picture

Michael Fremer does a wonderful job but I'd rather see more on what Kalman Rubinson is doing and more interviews with people like Jim Fosgate.

Alex's picture

Yes, more analog vinyl coverage, please. Also report more on tube gear, horn speakers, cassette tapes, and reel-to-reel playback. I know such technology is considered old, but analog sounds better and warmer, while digital sounds cold and harsh. Commercial CDs are overly compressed and equalized while analog mediums are mastered for audiophile listeners, so they have wider dynamic ranges and better stereophonic imaging. Commercial CDs are all mixed and mastered to sound like gangsta rap or nu-metal records, but audiophile vinyl sounds more like real music.

Jack Hannold's picture

Real high fidelity is analog!

Larry's picture

I always enjoy reading Mr. Fremer's discussing all things vinyl. Cover more and let's get Fidelity Research back in business!!!!!

Vade Forrester's picture

Although I'm a vinyl enthusiast, I realize the medium is really limited in availability and popularity. Your current coverage is thus quite sufficient.

Dale Rabeneck's picture

Yes - a few more articles on how to get more out of your current equipment in addition to more equipment reviews. Since vinyl is much less "set and forget" good info on DYI setup component matching, etc. would be interesting. I know that there is a lot of info available on the web (AA et. al.) but more concise information would be great.

Allen's picture

With the abundance of used vinyl available for about a $1 per title, it's a great way to explore new (old) music on the cheap. Let's see: highly compressed, over-hyped lip-sync material for $18.99 a pop in the mall vs clean used vinyl LPs for about the same price as the tax on a CD? Someone cue up the theme from Jeopardy and let the thinking begin.

Nelson Natal's picture

Most especially 'tables in the $1000 to 3000 range.

Nicolas's picture

There is an ever growing demand for new vinyl products and covering turntables, cartridges, phono pre-amps and records would be great service for the audiophile masses, both new and old. There is even a greater amount of audiophiles coming back to vinyl and a newer generation that is discovering vinyl and the art of analog bliss.

Pages

X