2012 Records To Die For Page 2


BRIAN CARPENTER'S GHOST TRAIN ORCHESTRA: Hot House Stomp: The Music of 1920s Chicago and Harlem
Brian Carpenter, trumpet, harmonica, voice; Dennis Lichtman, clarinet; Andy Laster, alto saxophone; Matt Bauder, alto & tenor saxophone, clarinet; Curtis Hasselbring, trombone; Ron Caswell, tuba; Brandon Seabrook, banjo; Mazz Swift, violin, vocals; Jordan Voelker, viola; Rob Garcia, drums
Accurate 5062 (CD). 2011. Danny Blume, eng., mix. DDD? TT: 38:46

It's great to hear pre-swing big-band charts done up in high fidelity. But Boston-based trumpeter Brian Carpenter takes liberties with music by Charlie Johnson, Fess Williams, Tiny Parham, and McKinney's Cotton Pickers, setting his Ghost Train Orchestra apart from your typical trad-jazz repertory group. Several GTO members have avant-garde pedigrees, which accounts for the freewheeling spirit (and occasional modern improv) on these tracks. Carpenter's erudite liner notes bring to life the history of the period. And his song choices—dig "Stop Kidding," by the startlingly innovative John Nesbitt—shed light on long-forgotten areas of jazz's past.


Ralph Peterson, drums; Jovan Alexandre, tenor saxophone; Josh Evans, trumpet; Pat Bianchi, organ; David Fiuczynski, guitar (tracks 10, 12)
Onyx Music (CD). 2011. Ralph Peterson, Pat Bianchi, engs., mix. DDD? TT: 78:47

Drummer Ralph Peterson, thunderous yet supple, is just the guy to tackle Woody Shaw classics "The Moontrane," "Beyond All Limits," and "Katrina Ballerina." The former 1980s "young lion" is now mentoring serious new talent, represented here by Josh Evans and Jovan Alexandre in the front line. Their soloing is ferocious, their horn personalities uncommonly rich and warm (and beautifully captured). Pat Bianchi brings a Larry Young vibe, and "Fuze" adds McLaughlin-esque shredding on two cuts, but Peterson isn't after replication: his originals, dedicated to mom, dad, and wife, give a personal dimension to what is surely a highlight of 2011.


PETER GABRIEL: New Blood (Special Edition)
with Ane Brun, Melanie Gabriel, Thomas Cawley, vocals; New Blood Orchestra, Louisa Fuller (leader), Ben Foster (conductor)
Real World 00038 (2 CDs). 2011. Peter Gabriel, prod., arr.; John Metcalfe, prod., arr., orchestrations, mix; Dickie Chappell, mix, eng.; Scott Barnett, Tobias Froberg, engs. DDD. TT: 2:32:06

I finished reading Walter Isaacson's biography of Steve Jobs as I prepared to write these brief reviews, and was struck by how adeptly Jobs re-created himself. He was not an artist as such, but Jobs's life illustrates how the artist who doesn't keep evolving ultimately fails. By that measure, Peter Gabriel's career is a continuing success, even if this 2011 album comprises second examinations of his earlier songs. Gabriel's Scratch My Back, which featured empathetic arrangements by John Metcalfe of other people's songs, was one of my 2011 "R2D4" picks; in New Blood, Metcalfe applies his orchestral imagination to a selection of Gabriel's own material. And again, there is no drum kit, no rhythm section. The sound of the orchestra, recorded at Air Lyndhurst in London, is rich and large, reminiscent of that on Joni Mitchell's Both Sides Now, from 2000, which was also recorded there. Occasionally the space on the accompaniment stands too much in contrast to the closeness of Gabriel's voice, particularly in the final track, "Solsbury Hill," which, for reasons explained in the booklet, is separated from the rest of the album by almost five minutes of ambient sound. Two favorites of mine from Security, "WallFlower" and "San Jacinto," are here, along with two favorites from So, "In Your Eyes" and "Don't Give Up," though Norwegian singer Ane Brun's excessive vibrato in the latter takes some getting used to after the glory of Kate Bush in the original, and the purity of Paula Cole in 1994's Secret World Live version. The second CD mainly comprises the orchestral backing tracks, which, if musically incomplete, bear witness both to the inventiveness of Metcalfe's arrangements and the completeness of Gabriel's musical imagination.


STEVE WINWOOD: Steve Winwood
Island 842 774-2 (CD). 1977. Steve Winwood, Chris Blackwell, Mark Miller Mundy, prods.; Phill Brown, eng.; Robert Ash, Ray Doyle, asst. engs.; Lee Hulko (Sterling Sound), CD mastering. AAD. TT: 37:25

At the fall 2011 AES Convention in New York, I was invited to take part in a workshop on "The Loudness Wars," chaired by Thomas Lund of TC Electronic. As part of the preparation of my segment, I went hunting for rock albums with respectable dynamic range. Not surprisingly, I couldn't find any from this century that weren't dynamically compromised. But among the jewels I did discover was Steve Winwood's first solo record. Overshadowed in sales by the subsequent Arc of a Diver, the LP release of Steve Winwood was in constant rotation on my Linn at the end of the 1970s, and when I ripped the CD into my iTunes library, Pure Music's meters informed me that this album had as much dynamic range as a good classical recording, its crest factor exceeding 20dB much of the time. Musically, the album wears its 35 years well. From the loping rhythm of the opener, "Hold On," to the anthemic closer, "Let Me Make Something in Your Life," both written with the late Jim Capaldi and featuring the dream team of Willie Weeks on bass and Andy Newmark on drums, you're struck by the sparseness of the soundstage created by engineer Phill Brown, despite the many instrumental flavors created by Winwood. ("Now this is an audiophile recording!" I commented in my AES presentation.) But the track that sticks in your memory is the only survivor from the original sessions, "Vacant Chair," cowritten with the late Vivian Stanshall in memory of Graham Bond. Alan Spenner's bass and John Susswell's drums underpin a hypnotic guitar riff from Julian Marvin as a multitracked Winwood chants "o-ku nsu-kun no-ko": in Yoruba dialect, "the dead are weeping for the dead."


MARC-ANDRÉ HAMELIN: Live at Wigmore Hall
Works by Alkan, Beethoven-Alkan, Busoni, Chopin-Balakirev, Medtner
Hyperion CDA66765 (CD). 1995. Ates Orga, prod.; Ken Blair, eng. DDD. TT: 71:56

One reason I like this recording is that I owned it for years before I was able to sort it out aurally, and it was a better system that made that possible. In that sense, it played a part in my discovery of good sound. Another reason I like it so much: It's one of the most realistic renderings of a back-of-the-theater perspective that I've heard. Musically, it's a purist's nightmare: a movement of Beethoven's Piano Concerto 3 and part of Chopin's Concerto 1, both arranged for solo piano. Several pieces—including Alkan's Trois Grandes Etudes, one each for left, right, and both hands—are intended for showing off. I love it anyway.


CLARK TERRY: Duke with a Difference
Clark Terry, trumpet, arr.; Johnny Hodges, alto saxophone; Paul Gonsalves, tenor saxophone; Britt Woodman, Quentin Jackson, trombone; Billy Strayhorn, piano; Luther Henderson, celeste; Tyree Glenn, vibes; Jimmy Woode, bass; Sam Woodyard, drums; Marian Bruce, vocals; Mercer Ellington, arr.
Riverside/OJC RLP-1108/OJC-229 (LP). 1957/1990. Orrin Keepnews, prod.; Jack Higgins, Jack Matthews, engs. AAA. TT: 38:09

Practically a Duke Ellington record—eight Ellington tunes played by five Ellington horns, plus Duke's bassist and drummer, Strayhorn on piano, and several other musicians with connections to the orchestra—but with a twist. There's no shortage of small-group Ellington records, but here the style is a bit more modern (for 1957) and improvisational. There is, apparently, a very good-sounding mono version of this, but my OJC reissue is great-sounding stereo. The sound is woody, airy, blatty, and great. Good times.


Capitol/Light in the Attic LITA 075 (2 LPs/CDs). 1959/2011. Ken Nelson, orig. prod.; orig. eng. not listed; Matt Sullivan, exec. & reissue prod.; Josh Wright, exec. reissue prod.; John Baldwin, remastering. ADA/ADD. TT: 70:36

Although much of their material had sacred connections, the glorious sounds of Charlie and Ira Louvin's singing was a profound influence on secular music—their close, high harmonies are especially reflected in the music of the Everly Brothers and the Byrds. Here, what may be their recorded masterpiece gets the deluxe reissue treatment, thanks to Seattle's superlative Light in the Attic crew. Thankfully, the album's already excellent sound has been retained, and its unforgettable original artwork—the brothers in white suits, behind them a looming red devil and roaring hellfire—is left untouched. Instead of a tribute record in which contemporary performers take stabs at their favorite Louvin tracks, disc 2 of this set collects 14 recordings from the Louvins' entire catalog, each selected by a modern admirer: Lucinda Williams, Mark Lanegan, Beck, Jim James, M. Ward, among others. Judging by the choices—which include "The Great Atomic Power," "When I Stop Dreaming," and "Knoxville Girl"—many of the decidedly secular and very noncountry alt-rock generation are big fans. Even better, the entire set is also available on two gorgeous 180gm LPs.


OTIS REDDING: The Great Otis Redding Sings Soul Ballads
Atco/4 Men with Beards 4M105 (LP). 1965/2002. No prod. or eng. listed. ADA. TT: 33:59

While the late, great Otis Redding—whose tragic death in December 1967 robbed the world of a singer whose potential seemed unlimited—was always great shouting out "Try a Little Tenderness" and his other upbeat hits, it was his pleading way with ballads that was at the heart of his prodigious talent. Coming after his 1964 debut album, Pain in My Heart, and its hit, the ballad "These Arms of Mine," this collection of slower numbers was where the greatest soul singer of them all established his elemental connection with the Stax house band of Steve Cropper (guitar), Donald "Duck" Dunn (bass), Booker T. Jones (organ/keys), and Al Jackson Jr. (drums)—not to mention the Memphis horns: Wayne Jackson (trumpet), Charles "Packy" Axton (tenor sax), and Floyd Newman (baritone sax). The horn charts on nearly every cut are superb, though those in Redding's "I Want to Thank You," and Axton's accents in Delbert McClinton's "Keep Your Loving Arms Around Me," are textbook examples of the Stax brass sound. The album ends with the classic, snappy "Mr. Pitiful," which shows that Redding can also wend his vocal way through a mean groove. This new 180gm pressing from 4 Men with Beards is an improvement over the original mono and stereo pressings; while those sounded decently crisp and dynamically acceptable, this new edition is much more spacious and detailed.


KENYA DANCE MANIA: Various Artists
Earthworks 3-1024-2 (CD). 1991. Trevor Herman, prod.; Frank Arkwright, mastering. AAD. TT: 72:05

The Kenyan benga style blends Congolese, Zimbabwean, and South African dance-pop with the music of the Luo people of southwestern Kenya. This collection includes killer benga hits of the 1970s and '80s—tightly meshed confections of sweet, slightly melancholy singing (mainly in Swahili or Luo), rhythmically twining guitars, hard-punching horns, throbbing bass lines, and clipped, thumping drums. Among the artists are Gabriel Omolo, whose "Lunch Time" went gold in 1973; H.O. Kabaselleh, whose career was interrupted by a prison term for sedition; Les Wanyika, a spin-off from the mostly Tanzanian group Simba Wanyika; and Wanyika Super Les Les, a spin-off from Les Wanyika. Most compelling, however, is the military band Maroon Commandos, whose stately 1976 smash, "Charonyi Ni Wasi," is surpassed only by their stomping 1989 hit, "Mawakaribishwa Na Maroon."


Stan Getz, tenor saxophone; Cal Tjader, vibraphone; Eddie Duran, guitar; Vince Guaraldi, piano; Scott LaFaro, bass; Billy Higgins, drums
OJC Remasters OJC-32690-02 (CD). 1958/2011. Sol Weiss, orig. prod.; Nick Phillips, reissue prod.; Joe Tarantino, remastering. AAD. TT: 42:47

This breezy-cool 1958 Fantasy date brought together Stan Getz with his then-unknown sidemen Billy Higgins and Scott LaFaro, and Cal Tjader with his sideman Vince Guaraldi and Guaraldi's own sideman (with his own trio), Eddie Duran. Although the group had never previously played together and didn't rehearse, they clearly clicked, and the session went down in one take. Getz is in especially good form, bopping smoothly in his best Lester-Young-meets-Charlie-Parker manner, but Tjader, in a straight-ahead setting rather than his usual Latin-jazz context, manages to keep up. The unheralded Duran and Guaraldi, belying his reputation for commercialism, are surprisingly solid, while Higgins and LaFaro are simply superb. Laid-back or up-tempo, every track is strong, but Guaraldi's briskly swinging composition "Ginza Samba," foreshadowing Getz's bossa nova collaborations with Charlie Byrd and Joao Gilberto, is irresistible.

soulful.terrain's picture

lady gaga???

Since when did this auto-tune freak show become worthy of any recognition as a singer?

I'd rather listen to 60 minutes of white noise..

Watthead's picture


+1 on that one

Ariel Bitran's picture

but the girl can actually sing.


and write well-constructed/melodically innovative pop songs.

himynameisjuan's picture

but what's up with the Lady Gaga cover art? There's a random "H" in there, and the image is eerily photoshopped. The image should look something like this, though not really, because the CD has entirely different artwork.

Regardless, Born This Way is too uplifting for my tastes. The first LP of The Fame or the entire The Fame Monster LP are much more listenable. They're far from my favorite albums of all time, but when playing records for friends I start with something familiar then move to more eclectic stuff.

Also, why do you guys post R2D4 lists a year behind? It took me a while to realize this a different list from the one in the latest issue.

John Atkinson's picture

why do you guys post R2D4 lists a year behind? It took me a while to realize this a different list from the one in the latest issue.

We started doing this 15 years ago, so that R2D4 being on-line free would not cannibalize sales of the February issue of the paper magazine. We've run a year behind ever since.

John Atkinson

Editor, Stereophile

John Atkinson's picture

We've run a year behind ever since.

Following a brief discussion with Web Monkey Jon Iverson, we will post the 2013 R2D4 in February and stay up-to-date in subsequent years. Just don't stop buying the paper magazine!

John Atkinson

Editor, Stereophile

deckeda's picture

... that revolved around having current content increase SEO which drives site and therefore advertiser traffic and that the print product is what it is either way.

Rust's picture

Seriously, Led Zep 4 should be replaced by Celebration in your soon to be posted list. Who would have thought that in their 60's the boys would have put on such a performance. The sound quality of the CD's is adaquate at best, the blue ray is much better. The various guest covers of Zep at the Kennedy Center were awful, on the other hand Beth Harts performance was stellar although she was rather constrained compared to...

......her "Live at Paradiso" of 2004. Get the DVD. One of the cleanest if not THE cleanest live rock preformance I've ever seen. What a live rock perfrormance in a smaller venue should be. She has that very rare thing missing in every other female rocker with the sole exception of Janis, power. IMO the best female rock artist ever, with the sole exception of Janis. The woman is a beautiful train wreck, I'm grateful her early success didn't kill her, a close thing.

Hendrix. Winterland. Live. The latest reissue sounds better than some, with the best performances (I rhink?) of a multi-night gig selected. It isn't just his use of feedback and tone, it's his phrasing. The best Hendrix release.

Holly Cole. "Romantically Helpless". She doesn't sound like anyone else. Quirky in a very original way. A different vocal range than you would normally expect. Unique phrasing. Her interpretations of classics like "Come Fly With Me" and "Loving You" are prime  examples.

Try listning to Sonny Landreth Live at the Grant Street Saloon. The best slide guitar player ever.

Try listening to pretty much anything Adrain Legg has done, brilliant technique.

Try going to Wolfgangs Vault, literally thousands of live performances, many filmed, from the Filmores East and West, Winterland and many other venues. Before huge arenas became the norm. Some of the recordings are very good indeed. Thank you Bill Graham.

On the very broad subject of Rock. Led Zeppelin and even Hendrix have been accused of raiding the music of others. Duh. Even Robert Johnson expanded on those who came before him. But Willie Dixon never sounded like Zep, and no one ever sounded like Hendrix.

If you want to see an enormous amount of roots americana, try Document Records. Leave it to the Brits to have the largest collection old blues and jazz commercially available anywhere I know of. You'd be surprised at how many of the 40's, 50's and 60's jazz greats dipped into the well of those who had gone before them.

Charles E Flynn's picture

Proprius Music's Cantate Domino is available in DSD, FLAC 96, and FLAC 192 at

and in 24/192 format at