Columns Retired Columns & Blogs |
SACD will do the job better.
When the format is finally launched around the world, DVD-Audio discs will have the ability to store and play back video information such as lyric sheets and pictures from recording sessions. Is this important to you?
I am looking for high-quality, high-resolution audio. It might be fun to explore one time some visual information related to the music, but when I sit down and listen to music I do not want to be bothered with the video stuff, as it only takes away attention from the listening. Please also keep the "-A" simple: no 20 menus to go through before you can listen to some music, like all that menu stuff in video. If I want, I will read the booklet enclosed with the disc.
I'm an audiophile; I don't own a television. If I did, I wouldn't want it near my audio equipment, where it could cause interference. A booklet with lyrics and pictures is always nice, but nothing tops a gatefold LP as a format for lyrics, still pictures, and liner notes.
The point of listening is to listen. Add a bunch of other activities and the music becomes "filler." I went to a production of "Into the Woods" last week. Someone brought a cell phone. It reminded me of the Vonnegut short story, "Harrison Bergeron," where people are required to handicap themselves so that everyone can be "equal." Of course, I'm talking about a book. Books don't require batteries or a power outlet. Neither does an acoustic guitar or a human voice (except for Andrea Bocelli).
Provided there is no degradation from adding the video portions, they have the potential to add something to the experience. The key here is that no musical compromises should occur as a result, and the cost difference between a video and non-video version should be reasonable (say 10 - 15 % at most.) Otherwise, give me an audio only machine.
Alhtough I would like documentaries of composers and musicians with excellent sound. It is interesting that DVD video was made (apparently) for discs which are bought vs. rented, since they do not handle scratches well. That seems strange!