I would also look at the Goldring GR-1.2, only $279 at HCM Audio. The Goldring Elektra on the Goldring GR-1.2 is a better cartridge than the other two, the Music Hall Tracker or Goldring Elan and the Ortofon OM 5E, respectively.

Cool advice, Jackfish.

I have bought multiple items from HCM and had a great experience.

Haha, it's funny that you should ask that. I just came here with the intention of posting exactly the same topic. It seems like these three turntables perform similarly, so I'm inclined to pick the Pro-Ject on price alone.