Columns Retired Columns & Blogs |
If I have a choice, vinyl is alwaysthe preferred and better format.
Downloads are taking off and it has been 25 years since CD was launched, yet audiophile demand for turntables and vinyl continues unabated. When did you last spin a record?
Unfortunately, I believe that there is far too much hype surrounding the sound of vinyl playback. In particular, I find two flaws. First, vinyl is a very awkward medium with which to work in terms of size and fragility. Secondly, I have found CD players which I believe play music more dynamically and musically "correct" against a pitch black background with absolutely no surface noise. Oh, no. I might have opened a Pandora's box. Mikey, are you there?
I still have more LPs than CDs, though there is probably more total time on the CDs. I like to get as close to the best from my LPs, so I have a good turntable and cartridge, and my preamp has an excellent phono preamp. I have CD reissues of some of my favorite performances and they usually sound as good or better. On the whole, I find CDs sound better than LPs. On the other hand, I see no reason to replace LPs I only play occasionally, and of course, many of the performances I have on LP are not available on CD.
I use CDs for convenience and for exploring new artists and repertoire. However vinyl has an amazing luxuriousness of sound and thus I tend to save playing LPs to the quiter times of my life when I can fully enjoy the experience and thus the music.
When poised with the choice of spending valuable and hard-to-come-by time listening to music, it only makes sense to spend it as wisely as possible. Thus listening to the best sound and music available. So I always choose vinyl! Then I don't feel I have cheated myself out of quality listeninng time. On those rare occasions when I do have extra time I will explore some of my other listening choices but not very often! Now for background/working-out music, even satelite radio would work!
I sold my last turntable in 1989. I have been tempted to buy again, but realize it would be entirely nostalgic and have sofar managed to resist. I do have a hand wound watch which meets my need for emotional attachment to times gone by.
To be fair, I've spent a year researching and auditioning systems to replace my (no laughing) 22-year-old, once state-of-the-art, pre-CD Naim amp and preamp. My Linn Sondek turntable will remain and I can't wait to plug it in to my new Meridian system (amp, pre-amp and CD 800) with my RudiStor headphone amp and 701 cans. Now I just need to find speakers here in Shanghai... D'oh!
I'm trying to think of a day that goes by when I don't spin the black circles. As I write this, I'm listening to U2's 1992 album Achtung Baby. Not U2's best album, but my original '92 vinyl pressing still beats all things digital.
Saturday night. I have to admit it was not much of an audiophile experience. I was listening to old worn out 45s from my youth. Neither the music nor the fidelity were sublime, but I enjoyed it a hell of a lot more than listening to digitized music.