Columns Retired Columns & Blogs |
Solid state for reliable, quick turn ons; tubes for sensuous sounds.
The last time we asked the tube-or-transistor question was almost three years ago (see the results <A HREF="http://www.stereophile.com/showvote.cgi?40">here</A>). So, we're curious if reader opinion has shifted when it comes to tube versus solid state amplifier technology.
SET is great in the midrange, but has its problems. Some solid state sound great at times, especially some of the lower distortion models with good power supplies. I do tend to get listener-fatigue faster from solid state. To my ears, nothing sounds more like music than a well-designed tube amp.
Audio Nirvana is tubes (any kind will do for me) for the midrange and highs and solid state for the bass. Practical considerations, such as being able to afford three meals a day and paying the mortgage, tend to make me end up with all solid state. If I hit the lottery or become a reviewer for Stereophile, I would no longer need to make such a painful compromise.
I listen to a push-pull tube amplifier (EL34s), and I prefer a smoother, liquid, non-fatiguing sound. I guess I also like the architecture of tubes, the glowing glass bottles, but I guess that takes me back to my youth, covers off the radios, soldering iron at the ready. I love my tube amplifier. Dying to build a single-ended one, though right now, push-pull is coming on.
Beautifull, musical, affordable, Antique Sound Lab tube power amp.35 watt per ch. EL34 based ultralinier.Audio Electronic Supply AE-3 pre amp, again great bang for the buck. Ive spent too much money replacing gear, now I'm in love with reproduced music in my home again!
Tubes for high/midrange (like Audio Research) mated with solid state (like Krell) to carry the bottom end. Sheer musical and visceral ecstacy if proper speakers are employed, that is. May I recommend the Pipedreams? No. I do not work for, nor am I in any way connected with the above mentioned companies; I just own their wonderful gear.
solid state all the way. who needs to worry about maintenance? amplifier manufacturers, if your reading this, how about more emphasis on cosmetics & heatsinks. an amplifier(espcially an expensive one) must please its owner even when turned off-- it all contributes to pride of ownership.
I still think the best ever that I ever had the plesure to listen to was audio note and Bruce Moore, IAM BLOWN away by the sound of the MUSICAL fidelity a3cr amp.Ihaven't heard the other ac3 stuff but it changed my mind about the ability of solid state to fool you
Nothing else sing beautifully like SET amp, simple and pure. In the world of mega watt amps, I'm using a pair of Welborne Labs Apollo I with 15Wpc of pure SET power driving Magnepan 1.5. Sound like I'm way under powered right? NO! Not for me. They sound great with great extension on both ends. People still laugh at me when I tell them about my 15Wpc and Maggie but they stop after they have listened to the system. Isn't it amazing how far we came since the first Triode?
I believe valves sound better however an SET at 8 watts cant give me 110db from 18hz to 22khz therefore I choose to buy solid state, the answer is to buy solid state amplifiers that still sound musical and emotionally involving and of course pure class A, I wont start a religious war by naming brands but I do feel its time stereophile reviewed a gryphon antilleon :)