I have owned a 5.1 reciever for five years, but integrating it into my video system just has not happened. Locating five speakers, never mind a subwoofer, into my family room just does not fit. I own six speakers which could and may be pulled in for an attempt, but as a long term solution. I do not think so.
What are your thoughts about multichannel music?

- Login or register to post comments

To really enjoy multichannel music, you really need a room big enough in order for the music to really flow into one coherent mix. I have played with and succeeded only with a small number of records to get it right. A lot of records have multichannel mixes that, in smaller rooms, become completely unnatural.

I find that multichannel plus video is better than multichannel music alone. David Gilmour's performance at the Robert Whyte Meltdown recorded in 2002 and Peter Gabriel live around 1993-4 both stand out in my mind as great multichannel captures of performances, but they are DVDs, not audio only. Forays into plain-jane multichannel music have included Steely Dan's re-release of Gaucho and a couple of multichannel SACDs on the Chesky label. I was less than impressed with those, although it could have been my system (which has been primarily designed for multichannel HT, not dedicated multichannel music). Overall, I'm interested, just not a follower quite yet.

It's not always good, that's for sure. Depending on how it's mixed, multichannel SACD or DVD audio can be well done or just awful. And even when it's well done, it's not always great. It has potential, and I still support it, but up to now I prefer two-channel.

I started multichannel in the '70's with a vintage Fisher tube integrated amp with a center channel mixdown. I got into DVD-Audio in 2000 after reading an article about Neil Young's disappointment with CD sound (I never abandoned vinyl or two-channel, btw). I am amused by the derogatory comments directed at multichannel. The same was said when stereo arrived. And it's not about "special effects" or gimmicky production. It's about listening to fully dynamic, high resolution music without strain, effort or distortion.

Hi, I believe it is sadly misunderstood how 5.1 reproduction properly done can advance the art compared to stereo of natural music reproduction, including the realism of musicians playing in front of you. Many of the responses here reflect this misunderstanding.
| Loudspeakers Amplification Digital Sources | Analog Sources Accessories Featured | Music Columns Features | Show Reports | Show Reports |
Recommended Components Blogs Latest News Community |
Shop Resources Subscriptions |


