You are here

Log in or register to post comments
CaptainVinyl1
CaptainVinyl1's picture
Offline
Last seen: 1 year 9 months ago
Joined: Mar 15 2012 - 9:00pm
subwoofer positioning

I never really experimented with where the ideal placement for speakers and sub would be. I have a wall to wall book shelf/entertainment center 6.5' high on the front wall. The main speakers are small DIY bookshelf designs that sit atop the outer book cases, angling down and in towards the listening area. My listening is about halfway split between settling into the chair at the ideal position, or working in the adjoining kitchen. I aim the speakers to focus on a point splitting the two positions.

The subwoofer was always right next to the sofa on the side wall. The sofa was centered on the wall, and the sub was immediately adjacent, acting as a side table. When the 1000 watt plate amp from Parts Express blew out for the second time, I found a very old 10 watt Sansui receiver for $4 at a thrift store. To see if the thing even worked, the easyest way was to hook the subwoofer up to it.

The first listen of the sub through the Sansui produced barely audible thumping. Nothing tuneful or impressive. I was about to disconnect and relegate the Sansui to bedroom computer duties, when for kicks I decided to try moving the sub around. I moved it to a point 14" from the wall to the back of te sub and then 28" from the side of the sub to the face of the book case..

Damn Son!!!  Even with only 10 watts I was now hearing the deepest, clearest, and highly tuneful bass I ever heard inmy house. Obviously the 10 watts could not handle demanding bass or LFE passages, but I was sold on the importance of speaker positioning. Now I have a mighty 20 watt receiver that cost a whole $7, and I actually find myself turning the volume down to the sub on certain recordings.

Kal Rubinson
Kal Rubinson's picture
Offline
Last seen: 3 hours 59 min ago
Joined: Sep 1 2005 - 9:34am
Location, location,

Location, location, location.

Subwoofer positioning is critical because its entire frequency range is in the range where the room dimensions create peaks and valley in response that are spatially distributed in the room.  Put the sub in a null and you get very little out of it (at that particular frequency).  Put it in another site and you get a strong emphasis of another frequency.  Put it in a corner and you excite all the modes which leads to increased but irregular output.  (BTW. a similar phenomenon applies to finding a good spot for the listening position.)

The standard recommendation is to put the sub in the listening position, play some LF pink noise and crawl around the room until the bass response seems linear.  Better is to crawl around with a mic and RTA.  When you find that spot.  Put the sub there, sit back and enjoy.

BTW, you might reconsider your L/R speaker setup and try to optimize it for the listening spot on the sofa.  It will never sound great in the kitchen, so there's no reason to compromise the MLP for it.

Kal

  • X
    Enter your Stereophile.com username.
    Enter the password that accompanies your username.
    Loading