Columns Retired Columns & Blogs |
November 11, 2007 - 6:53pm
#1
record clamp, to buy or not to buy?
Loudspeakers Amplification | Digital Sources Analog Sources Featured | Accessories Music |
Columns Retired Columns & Blogs |
Loudspeakers Amplification Digital Sources | Analog Sources Accessories Featured | Music Columns Retired Columns | Show Reports | Features Latest News Community | Resources Subscriptions |
I'm not at all clear on how a record weight or clamp could affect record wear. A clamp should not affect the motor in any way. A good clamp should first provide better contact between the LP and the platter or mat. It should also flatten slightly warped discs. I haven't used the Michell clamp but I suspect it does a fair job at the former function. I doubt it can manage much in way of the latter; but you'll need a table with a dedicated spindle/clamp mechanism (or vacuum hold down) to begin to really take warp wow out of most discs. Buy the clamp and try it on a slightly warped disc. If you see the woofers of your speakers moving less with the clamp in place, it's helping.
A record weight might affect bearing wear to a small degree but typically not enough to be of concern for the average listener with a decent table.
Jan,thank you!i have some very valuable records,and record wear is really what concerns me.Can you tell me the stylus
affects in any way record grooves while playing, if record do not lie flat on the turntable platter.Thank you
I agree- a good clamp is essential to a serious TT setup. Various materials seem to also act a sink to micro vibrations and in some cases, if it's heavy enough adds some inertia to the whole platter aasembly. Mostly it just gives better contact and prevents and slipping. If you have a felt mat then be careful about not over tightening the clamp or you might get uneven pressure. Speaking of mats- I got the Funk Firm Acromat and was amazed at the drop in noise level and increase in detail. Well worth the upgrade.
http://www.needledoctor.com/Funk-Firm-Achromat-Universal-Record-Mat?sc=10
Not laying flat I suppose means warped. You're asking a question that is somewhat irrelevant. The disc is warped, therefore, it has already been damaged. The amount of increased wear on such a disc is not the issue. But as the stylus tracks the rising side of the warp, stylus pressure increases. The good news is as the stylus tracks the falling side of the warp, stylus pressure decreases. Depending on the disc and the cartridge, either too low or too high a VTF might cause a slight increase in groove wear. I suspect that if the disc is warped so badly as to cause a severe increase in tracking pressure, there are other issues of concern. As I said, watch the woofers in your speakers when you play a warped disc.
Forum member Buddha offered this helpful and thoughtful post:
Thank you all guys!