How Not to Change a Tweeter

In April of 2011, after watching one of the many iterations of The Due Diligence perform at Silent Barn, the soundman made an announcement: “We have a bunch of old music gear for sale in the venue’s basement.” I jumped from my seat.

Dusty guitar amps, dirt-speckled stage light fixtures, and busted drivers piled atop each other on a series of shelves. I inspected each piece of gear carefully. Atop the highest shelf, I found them. Though covered in scratch marks and gum, the logo was clear: Polk Audio. The “i" was dotted with a little heart. I fell in love.

I asked to test them out. The soundman stripped one end of a quarter inch cable and plugged it into to the back of one of the speakers. He plugged the terminated end of the quarter inch into the unbalanced output of a powered mixer. Music played. We followed the same procedure with speaker number two. A flask or two of whiskey deep, all I heard was awesome. I brought home a pair of Polk Audio Monitor 7s for $30.

Listening at home, I became aware that one of the speakers’ tweeters was not functioning.

The Polk Audio Monitor 7s sat unused for two years.

I informed Polk Representative Adam Sohmer of my situation. He told me that Polk was going to make me new tweeters for the speakers. Two months later, two small boxes each identified as “Authentic Polk Replacement” arrived at the Stereophile office.

I asked Adam, “Will I have to solder?”

“Yes! Definitely.”

I was excited for this new opportunity. To help me in the process, I invited friend and old band-mate Darrell Dumas to my house. He’s a guitar gear geek who builds his own pedals. He was more than down to teach me how to solder and help me in the speaker reconstruction process.

Before Darrell arrived, I removed the tweeter to confirm that we were indeed going to need to solder, and it was not just pushpins like my Usher S-520s. Bulbous metallic bubbles connected the cables coming from inside the speaker to the tweeter. Soldering was required.

Darrell arrived and we put on our safety glasses. Larry the cat watched.


This is Darrell. He plays in a band called Hot Twins.

We placed the speaker, back down, on a piece of cardboard in case any melted solder dripped to the ground. Using my brand new Weller WES51 Soldering Iron, we applied the hot iron to a pre-existing joint and melted away the old solder. Following this, we cut off the old wire and stripped off about an inch of insulation.

We thread the exposed wire into the new tweeter’s binding posts. Using a 0.5-ounce container of acid-free Benzomatic rosin core solder, we held the tip of the solder to the destined joint location and touched the iron to the solder. The solder melted over the wire and binding post and created a shiny little orb.

After soldering the first tweeter, we discovered the faceplate of the new tweeter was smaller than the old one. The correct thing to do in this situation would have been:

a) Pause all work.
b) Contact Polk Audio and inform them of the mismatched faceplate size.
c) Tell Darrell to go home.

But that’s not what we did. Instead, we did what most musicians would do: Improvise!

The first idea was to try and exchange the faceplates of the old and new tweeters. While there were four screws on the outer ridge of the faceplate to hold the tweeter to the cabinet, there were also four screws around the tweeter’s dome that seemed to hold the dome and the voice coil to the faceplate. We removed those four screws from the old and new tweeters. Unfortunately, the dome and voice coil of the old tweeter were permanently affixed to the faceplate unlike the dome and voice coil of the new tweeter, which could be separated. This ruined our ingenious plan.


The old tweeter.


The new tweeter.

When I showed JA the pictures the following week, he gasped and nearly scolded, “Don’t do that! You’ve killed the tweeter.” Eternally calm, this is the most shaken I’ve ever actually seen JA. What did I do? “You can’t post this!” he commanded.

I asked him, “If there are screws there, then why shouldn’t I be able to unscrew it?” This still seems like a reasonable question.

“Because the tweeter’s dome and voice coil are lined up precisely above the magnet with a jig by a trained assembly-person. The exact centering of the tweeter is required so that it may move in and out of the circular gap between the magnet and the central polepiece in the correct fashion.”

“Oh.”

“There could also be some ferrofluid in there that you let out.”

“But the tweeter worked!”

“It worked?”

Since we couldn’t combine the old faceplate with the new tweeter dome and voice coil, we devised a surgical procedure. We positioned the faceplate and re-installed tweeter dome and voice coil so at least two of the holes matched up to the cabinet. We drove a nail into the cabinet where the mismatched holes lined up and twisted screws into the newly formed openings. After hooking the speaker up to my amplifier, we played the high frequency test tones from Stereophile’s Editor’s Choice. The tweeter worked! We got lucky.

It was now time to change the tweeter on the speaker that was actually broken. When I opened this speaker, a cloud of white dust emerged. We followed the same procedure: cut the wire, strip the wire, thread the wire, hold solder and iron to joint and melt together. We performed the same nail-through-cabinet surgery and hooked the speaker up to the amp. This time the tweeter did not work. Mind you, this was not the tweeter we had performed our previous disassembly, which could have potentially killed the tweeter. Our soldering the second time around was even more careful than the first.

We opened the back of the speaker to see if we could notice something funny in the crossover, but at that point, Darrell and I realized we both had no idea what we were doing. I’ll be taking the speaker to JA’s house for further investigation.


The crossover.
Share | |
COMMENTS
volvic's picture

My old Castle Acoustic's tweeter would regularly stop working, I would always have to open up the speaker by carefully removing the woofer and locate the burnt fuse.  See if the crossover has one and check to see that it isn't burnt.  Just a thought. 

Nick 

Ariel Bitran's picture

There area  couple fuses in the back of the crossover on the rear of the speaker

this was actually the first thing I checked when i discovered the non-functioning tweeter. however, changing the fuses did not solve the problem.

on the day of the project above, I even re-checked this by switching out the fuses from the functioning speaker to the broken one. no go.

volvic's picture

It was worth a try, keep at it you will find the culprit soon enough.  

JasonVSerinus's picture

I'm certain Larry is the culprit. 

X
Enter your Stereophile.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
Loading